← Real Estate Pros
Real Estate Pros · November 18, 2026 · 29 min listen

Why Real Estate Investors Should Treat Recruiting Like Sales | Luke Smitherman

With Luke Smitherman

Show summary

Luke Smitherman, founder of Crush Recruiters, explains how his recruiting firm specializes in real estate investing and why proactive, sales-minded outreach beats simply waiting for applicants. He also shares lessons from entrepreneurship, ways to build stronger candidate and client relationships, and practical advice for founders who want to hire effectively.

Key takeaways

  • Recruiting should be treated as a sales job: just as you wouldn't send HR or marketing to close a seller lead, you shouldn't send an administrative assistant to handle a candidate's first call.
  • Candidates are evaluating the company just as much as the company is evaluating them, so the first impression (who makes that first call) matters a lot.
  • Founders should remove themselves from the initial candidate call because no hired employee, especially a 1099 commission-only salesperson with no equity, will ever care about the business as much as the founder does.
  • A better process: have a sales-oriented person or recruiter handle the first call to pitch the company and get the candidate bought into the culture, then bring in the founder once the candidate is already partly sold (Luke estimates getting them '50% of the way up' before the founder talks to them, versus '10%' if the founder does the first call).
  • Luke built his own AI-powered applicant tracking system about a year ago, tailored to his workflow, including a feature that automatically pulls resumes/attachments from his email instead of relying on manual entry.
  • Crush Recruiters, founded in 2019, has placed about 80 candidates over its first five years; Luke's goal for 2027 is to place 80 candidates in that single year.
  • Many qualified candidates come from adjacent industries like roofing, home restoration, and solar, who want to move into real estate investing but don't know how to break in; recruiters can help surface this pool rather than relying solely on Indeed or LinkedIn applicants.

In this episode

  1. 00:00Recruiting Is a Sales Job
  2. 00:57Meet Luke Smitherman
  3. 02:18How Crush Recruiters Started
  4. 03:57From Coffee Entrepreneur to Recruiter
  5. 06:22Why Empathy Matters in Recruiting
  6. 09:43Building an AI Recruiting System
  7. 11:17The Goal: 80 Hires in 2027
  8. 12:11Great Candidates Want Real Estate Jobs
  9. 14:21Relationships Have to Work Both Ways
  10. 17:20Need Less, Give More
  11. 18:33Why Recruiting Is Sales
  12. 19:17Why Founders Should Step Back
  13. 21:11How to Connect With Luke

About Luke Smitherman

Luke Smitherman is the owner of Crush Recruiters, a recruiting firm he says is one of the only ones focused specifically on the real estate investment space. He started the company in August 2019 after previous careers selling industrial laundry services for Aramark and running a coffee roasting company in Austin. His early clients included Orange 142, InfoDNA, and Big State Home Buyers in Houston, the last of which remains his longest-standing client.

Listen to the audio

“Recruiting is a sales job. If you pay for a lead, a seller lead, you're not gonna send your HR department out there to close the deal. You're not going to send your marketing department out there to close the deal. You're going to send a salesperson out there to close the deal.”

Luke Smitherman

“Nobody on the planet is ever going to care about the business as much as you do. You shouldn't expect them to.”

Luke Smitherman

“If y'all knew how many candidates want to work for you, it's unbelievable.”

Luke Smitherman
recruitinghiring for real estate investing companiesfounder-led salescandidate experienceapplicant tracking systemsentrepreneurshipbusiness relationshipsCrush Recruiters

Questions answered in this episode

Why should real estate investing companies treat recruiting like a sales process?

Luke Smitherman argues that just as you wouldn't send HR or marketing staff to close a seller lead, you shouldn't let non-sales staff handle the first call with a job candidate. Candidates are evaluating the company just as much as they are being evaluated, so that first call needs a sales-oriented person who can sell the role and the culture effectively.

Should the founder be the one doing initial candidate interviews?

Luke recommends founders remove themselves from the first call. He says no candidate, especially one in a commission-only, 1099 role with no equity, benefits, or salary, will ever view the business the way the founder does, so the founder can't evaluate them through the right lens that early. Better to have a recruiter or sales leader get the candidate partly bought in first, then bring in the founder.

Where do good candidates for real estate investing roles come from if not just job boards?

Luke says many strong candidates come from industries like roofing, home restoration, and solar, people with applicable sales and service skills who are burned out on their current industry and have seen real estate investing content on YouTube, Facebook, or LinkedIn but don't know how to break in. He gets regular LinkedIn messages from such candidates asking about openings.

What operational tool does Luke Smitherman use to run his recruiting business?

About a year ago he used an AI app builder to create his own applicant tracking system tailored to his workflow. One key feature automatically monitors his email and pulls in resumes or attachments as they come in, so nothing falls through the cracks even though he admits he wouldn't reliably do that step manually.

What are Luke Smitherman's placement numbers and goals for Crush Recruiters?

Crush Recruiters started in August 2019 and has placed about 80 candidates over its first five years. Luke's goal is to place 80 candidates in 2027 alone, and he says he's willing to work with companies that have had bad experiences with other recruiting agencies and take on more of the risk himself to prove the model.

Resources and links

Full transcript

Luke Smitherman (00:00)

The number one thing that I like to say, I’d say it in pretty much every single one of my candidate calls or my client calls if I’m, talking to a prospect who’s thinking about implementing recruiting is a sales job. if you pay for a lead, a seller lead, you’re not gonna send your HR department out there to close the deal.

You’re not going to send your marketing department out there to close the deal. You’re going to send a salesperson out there to close the deal.

Quentin Edmonds (00:57)

Hello, everyone. Welcome to the Real Estate Pros Podcast. I am your host, Q Edmonds, and y’all see the smile. I’m excited. I’m really excited to be here today. I have another fantastic guest. Y’all know I love just learning from other people’s experience. And so can’t wait for us to talk to him.

he’s one of the only companies that really focused on investors. I believe I had that right, focusing on the real estate space. And so I’m excited because he’s rare. We talked a little bit and both of us was brainstorming, and we think he may be one of or the leader within this space.

Let him put more language to this and hopefully I’m not butchering it. But I’m excited because we get to learn today from Mr. Luke Smithherman. Mr. Luke, how you doing today, sir?

Luke Smitherman (01:43)

Hey, doing great. Glad to be here.

Quentin Edmonds (01:45)

Absolutely,

man. I’m glad you’re here too, sir. let me say thank you for your time. Let me start there. I value your time. I value people that come on because you can be doing anything else, but you’re here giving us some of your time. So, man, I appreciate you being on, Luke. and really honestly, I’m in type. I like to dive right in. So I would love for you to tell the people what’s your main focus these days. If you don’t mind, give us a little origin story, how you got into the mix that you’re in.

And then sir, tell us where you are in the world because people would always love to know geographically what people are. And so Mr. Luke, sir, you have the floor, my friend.

Luke Smitherman (02:18)

Yeah. thanks for having me. my name’s Luke Smitherman. I’m the owner of Crush Recruiters. We are one of, if not the only recruiting company that focuses on the real estate investment space. I’ve been operating for seven years. We started in twenty nineteen, at the end of twenty nineteen, so August. So if you think about that, I did it for four or five months and then a pandemic hit.

And so it was like, what did I get myself into, but within a month or two, all of our clients, especially in this space, started hiring even more. so that was definitely a huge, huge blessing. I got into recruiting, oddly enough, I think that this is a pretty similar story to a lot of people who get into recruiting. unless recruiting is your first job out of college, you end up just falling into it.

later in life. for me, my first job out of college was with an industrial laundry service company called Aramark. It’s similar to a Cintas or a UniFirst or Alsco. but basically what I was doing is I would go around to restaurants or to automotive shops or dealerships and I would sell them industrial laundry services. hey, we’ll rent you the uniforms once a week. We’ll come and we’ll pick them up. We’ll wash them. We’ll bring by clean ones.

And that was a service. I did that for six years, but right around the two year mark, whenever I was there, I started getting these calls from recruiters from other companies or from staffing agencies or recruiting firms. And they were all trying to sell me jobs, right? hey, we think you’d be a great fit for this role. we love your experience for this role, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And I took a lot of those calls. I never ended up

actually making a move. but I took a lot of those calls and one thing that was very apparent to me through a lot of them was it just felt very transactional. and a lot of people it was as if they had, six questions that they were given and they just needed to answer those six questions. and so, for me it didn’t feel all that personal. and maybe that’s why I didn’t

end up jumping ship and going to another company. after Aramark, I ended up starting a coffee roasting company in Austin. and that was much more of a passion project. got kicked in the teeth. I’m a firm believer that, everybody who wants to be an entrepreneur, you gotta get kicked in the teeth. it changes your perspective on everything. and so

I did that for three years and towards the end of that business as I was thinking through what’s next, I remembered all these recruiters who used to call me whenever I was with Aramark. And I was like, if I could end up doing that. I did a little bit of research on how recruiters charge and, how they got clients and stuff like that. And I just started cold calling companies in Houston and in Austin and ended up

Bringing on a company called Orange 142. They are a digital advertising agency. So that was my first client. I ended up bringing on a client called InfoDNA, which is more of a software, enterprise software company, and they were in Houston. That was my second client. My third client was a company called Big State Home Buyers in Houston. and they have been my longest standing client ever since then,

I’ve worked with them quite a bit anytime they had an opening. but that’s really where I learned about the industry as a whole. and so yeah from there we just grew and brought on new clients and I just fell in love with the industry and the space and got introduced to other people and just grew that way.

Quentin Edmonds (05:32)

Love it, man. Thank you, sir. Thank you for taking us through the journey. when people talk and share their stories, I see in pictures. And so I am familiar with Aramark. And so yeah, I’ve seen it around here in my town. And so I love it, man. Thank you for taking us through the journey. I think there are so many nuggets in the journey. I think we learn our why in the process, right? or sometimes our why powers our process,

I often say destiny has no wasted moments.

Luke Smitherman (05:59)

I like that.

Quentin Edmonds (05:59)

Right? we are borrowing from every leg of the journey, right? So, Mr. Luke, Aramark, coffee, recruitment, all these pivots, landed where you are. I would love to know what has the journey revealed to you about yourself? Has it made you more patient? Has it made you more humble? Has it increased your tenacity? what has the journey revealed to

Mr. Luke about Mr. Luke.

Luke Smitherman (06:22)

that’s a great question. there’s a word that’s buzzy right now that I really wasn’t familiar with until six or seven years ago. And it’s empathy. And so I didn’t realize there are two ways that you can gain empathy. Number one,

You can be born with it. And I think that you’re just inclined to be able to put yourself in other people’s shoes. And that’s me. almost to the extent where I feel like I’m psychic, I just have a real ability to be able to tell what people need at any given time. and I feel like it’s my mission to do what I can to make sure that they get what they need. the other way that you can build empathy is to go through something.

similar to what that person is going through. so unemployment, right? So if you’ve never been unemployed before and every job you’ve ever gotten has been really easy for you to get. My wife’s a speech therapist. Okay. ever since she graduated, has never had any trouble whatsoever getting a job. Yeah. if you’ve never worried about getting a job

Then it’s really difficult for you to understand the struggle that other people go through whenever they have been unemployed for five or six months. The immediate answer is, well, they just need to apply to more jobs or they need to fix their resume or whatever it is, But they don’t understand that there’s something else at play. and so, the whole journey, I’m very experiential.

whether good, bad, ugly, whatever it is, I just find myself being drawn to new experiences. so entrepreneurship was something that wasn’t even on my radar. my single mom household, she worked the same job for 25 years and never saw her really work anything else. she was in banking, she was in human resources for a bank and

that was the exposure. So I, graduated college thinking gonna get a job, gonna work at the same company for twenty five years. and that’s not what ended up happening for me. So yeah, the whole journey has been revealing about not just who I am, but what I’m capable of and what you can do and what your mission

in life is.

Quentin Edmonds (08:20)

Luke so well said, man. I was actually taking notes on as you was explaining, and so much of what you said hit me in parallel to some of the things that’s going on in my life. And it’s just some buzzbirds. And I’ll talk about it a little bit more later because I want to keep this focused on you. But thank you, man. I want to say thank you again for just that explanation. I really, really appreciate it. Luke,

I want to talk operations and systems a little bit, right? Because we all have operational things that we put into place that works for us, right? So I would love to know from your vantage point, your day to day, what are some operational things that you’ve put in place that has either changed the way you do business or actually added, value or success to the way you do business now? Talk to me a little bit about some operational things you have in place.

Luke Smitherman (09:43)

Yeah, so about a year ago, whenever all of these AI app builders started becoming a bit more popular, I used one to create my own applicant tracking system. and so for me it’s tailored to the way that I work. and so as dumb as this sounds, I’m sure that there was a much easier way to fix this 10 years ago, even 15 years ago.

I wasn’t privy to this information, but even something as easy as somebody sending me their resume in an email. I would have a conversation with a client, I’d say, or a candidate and say, hey, just email me your resume and I’ll put it together with my notes and I’m going submit it to the hiring manager. They would end up sending that email with their resume. And then for whatever reason, I would send it along to the company, but I would never take that resume and

put it in my applicant tracking system. Now, after I’ve created my own, and because I know about myself that I’m not going to take the time to download it from the email and add it to the Applicant Tracking system I just have a function in that applicant tracking system to where it monitors my email. Anytime that there’s an attachment or a resume that is submitted

it automatically just pulls it from my email. So things like that. it’s built around the way that I work. It helps me move faster. It helps me not forget about things. It helps things not fall through the cracks. it’s been a lot of help for me.

Quentin Edmonds (11:00)

yeah. Love it. Thank you, man. I love the way we are finding new ways. Cause AI is such a big buzzword but how we’re finding new ways to implement different things and different systems and operations. and I love it, man. What’s next for you, Luke? what is the next real goal? What are you looking to solve at scale next, sir?

Luke Smitherman (11:17)

it’s a big goal. and let me preface this by saying, I’m willing to do whatever it takes to make this work. and that’s a pitch to whoever hears this. so make me an offer. but my goal for next year is to place eighty candidates in the industry. I’ve placed about eighty candidates over the last five years.

So moving into 2027, my goal is to place 80 candidates in 2027 alone. it’s definitely doable. and I again am willing to work with companies who maybe recruiting has been out of reach for them. maybe they’ve had bad experiences with other agencies and so they’re a little gun shy, whatever it is.

Let’s start the conversation. And I am willing to do whatever it takes to prove myself to them and take on the risk myself. because I’m a believer in, what we do and the people that we’ve put in place so far.

Quentin Edmonds (12:04)

Yes, sir. Listen, place eighty candidates. I voted down, man. I’m in solidarity with you, but it can have me. That’s for sure.

Luke Smitherman (12:11)

I try and tell clients this whenever I talk to them. I was like, if y’all knew how many candidates want to work for you? it’s unbelievable. I get messages every day in my LinkedIn mailbox just from people who are just like, Hey, are there any openings in this area? Hey, are there any openings in this area? And

I’m sure that there are. my advice is you can always Google these companies and reach out to them directly. but there are so many good candidates who are coming from roofing or home restoration or solar or something like that where they’re just done with that industry, but they have these applicable skills to move into this world and

They see all of these YouTube videos about, real estate investing. They see all these, gurus on Facebook or LinkedIn or whatever it is. And they want to get into the industry, but they don’t know how to. and so, I try and tell clients that all the time and for whatever reason, half of them are still like, Well, we’ll just rely on, the people coming in through Indeed or LinkedIn or whatever. Okay, that’s fine.

Yeah. let me know if it doesn’t work.

Quentin Edmonds (13:12)

yeah. so Luke, I just got real giddy because I’m gonna love asking you this question. I ask everyone that comes on this question, but man, am I gonna love asking you this? So everyone that comes on, I like to hear their unique perspective on the word relationship. And so I am gonna absolutely love hearing your unique perspective on relationship, whether it’s building healthy business relationships.

with clients or with people that you’re hiring, people that you’re placing. So for you, I would love to hear your unique perspective on that word relationship.

Luke Smitherman (14:21)

Yeah, that’s good.

I think that a relationship it implies that it’s two people working together, right? and everything that comes along with that is you gotta have respect for the other person and their goals. And I think that the best relationships, whether it’s marriage

Whether it’s with your friend, whether it’s with a business partner, whether it’s with a coworker, whether it’s a subordinate, whether it’s with a boss, literally doesn’t matter, whether it’s with podcast hosts here, the best relationships are the ones where we’re selfless and our job is to elevate the other person, right? So if we can take a step back and say, in my marriage, right? my goal is to

Forget about myself and exalt my wife, help my wife, whatever it is. that works really, really well whenever her mindset is the same thing, right? So if her mindset is, my mindset is to forget about myself and to exalt my husband and do that. It’s the same exact thing in business. my best clients are the ones who take the time with me and they sit down and say, How can we help you? Right. what do you need from us to be successful to

place this candidate. I will go above and beyond. I will do whatever it takes to get that person the best possible candidate out there. The ones that are a struggle to work with are the ones who say, just bring me some candidates, whoever you got, whatever. And I call and I’m like, hey, what’d you think about that person? no answer. Hey, would love to chat about how the interview went. No answer. No response.

It’s really, really difficult to have a successful relationship when one person is more invested in the other person. So that’s what I believe about it.

Quentin Edmonds (16:01)

So well said. It actually gave me chills, man. I’ma share with you, just based on what you said, something my father asked me one day. I came to his house. we were writing a book together, I was gonna just write about his life. So I was gonna interview him. And so I’m on a time crunch. So I’m sitting down, I’m ready to go, Luke. And as soon as I sit down, my father says to me, out of nowhere.

He says, son, have you ever seen a tree eat its own fruit?

what? He said, son, have you ever seen a tree eat its own fruit? And I sat a little bit and I said, no. He said, right. He said, because the design is for it to grow fruit for someone to pluck from. It’s designed to nourish somebody. And he’s like, as you grow fruit, people are gonna pluck from your tree. And it’s gonna be painful at times because they literally.

Plucking from your tree, but you’re nourishing them. He said, Here’s the amazing thing though. He says, there’s another tree that’s growing fruit for you. that’s the ecosystem that I see with what you just said. how can I help you? Because if I’m helping you, or even what you use with the marriage, which was brilliant, as I esteem you, you esteem me, you eat my fruit, I’ll eat your fruit.

And this way we’re directing each other. And that’s the way I see businesses, a healthy business, the same way, as you so eloquently explained. And so yeah.

Luke Smitherman (17:20)

it’s like that in society too. we all have different gifts. We’re all part of a collective, human group. And we work best whenever we forget about ourselves I have a good friend, his name’s Vince Fabro. He’s a comedian, he’s also a public speaker, and he goes around to businesses and college campuses and stuff like that and does keynote speeches. But his whole thing

is need less and give more. And so it’s the same thing, right? that’s how society itself solves a lot of problems if that’s everybody’s mindset. You gotta take ego out of it, and you gotta look to help other people. You gotta think less about yourself.

Quentin Edmonds (17:57)

Man, yeah. I’m taking notes. You talk, man. You talk, sir. Luke, man. I so appreciate you coming on, man. we got a little bit of time. I definitely want to tell people how to get in contact with you. But before we get there, I do want to ask, because I’ve been asking you lot of questions. I just want to make sure we don’t leave any stone unturned. So is there anything you came in with something on your mind, maybe even in your notes, right? That you wanted to say about your business.

wanna say about recruiting or something that you feel like would be motivational, educational, I just wanna make sure that if there’s anything on your heart that you get a chance to speak it. So I just wanna make space for that, man.

Luke Smitherman (18:33)

Yeah.

The number one thing that I like to say, I’d say it in pretty much every single one of my candidate calls or my client calls if I’m, talking to a prospect who’s thinking about implementing recruiting is a sales job. if you pay for a lead, a seller lead, you’re not gonna send your HR department out there to close the deal.

You’re not going to send your marketing department out there to close the deal. You’re going to send a salesperson out there to close the deal.

So many companies who are, founder-led, maybe it’s a small company, five people or so, they tend to try and do it all themselves. and they’ll make that first call with the candidate from an administrative assistant or something like that.

And you have to realize that the candidates are evaluating you just as much as you’re evaluating the candidate. That’s the world that we live in today. and so you have to make sure that you’re putting your best foot forward. you need to have a sales oriented person at least handling that first call with a candidate. That’s where we come in.

The other thing I would say about that same process is if the founder is the one who’s doing all of those first calls, I would say try and pull yourself out of it because nobody on the planet is ever going to care about the business as much as you do. you shouldn’t expect them to, right? they have no equity in the business. most of the time it’s a commission only job, 1099. there’s no

Salary, no benefits, whatever it is. Sometimes there aren’t any leads provided, whatever it is. You can’t expect them to look at the business the same way that you do. It’s very important, I think, for founders and owners to be able to separate themselves out of that initial conversation because they’re not able to look through the right lens with the candidates. it’s better to have somebody like me or another recruiter or

even a sales leader on your team, to have that initial conversation with them, pitch them on the company, get them bought into the culture, to the process, to the company as a whole, and then introduce the founder to them. Because at that point, the founder is talking to somebody who is, at least about right here, 50% of the way up. Ideally that person would be 100% way up, but they might be 50% up after talking with somebody else.

Whereas if it’s the initial call, maybe that person’s down here at ten percent. I’m a firm believer you have to remove yourself from that situation until later on in the process. But those are the two things that I would wanna pitch to people, if they’re struggling with finding, the right people.

Quentin Edmonds (20:59)

Absolutely. Well, Luke Man, we’ve heard you, sir. Listen, if someone wanted to reach out to you, connect with you, collaborate with you, hire you, learn more about what you’re doing, all that good stuff, how can they get in contact with you, sir?

Luke Smitherman (21:11)

email is luke@crushrecruiters.com call my cell phone. It’s 251-270-0723. we can put them in the show notes. but those are the two best ways. You shoot me an email or text or phone call and I’m usually pretty good about responding within, ten minutes or so. but would love to hear from whoever, even if it’s

not from recruiting. If there’s something else that you want to chat about and that you found interesting or if there’s any way that I can help somebody, then I’m happy to do it.

Quentin Edmonds (21:39)

Absolutely. Well, let me say three things to you sincerely. Again, one first thing, thank you for your time. I value it. Thank you for giving us some of your time. Secondly, man, I would say thank you for the gift of your authenticity, the gift of your integrity. I would even say the gift of your vulnerability. I really believe when we share our stories, whether it be talking about our business, talking about ourselves.

I believe we cast seed out there. And that seed, somebody can take that seed and literally plant it in their business, in their mindset, what they’re doing, and really reap a harvest. So I really believe you came on and cast some seed, man, with your gift of integrity, your gift of vulnerability, your gift of authenticity. So I appreciate you showing up as your authentic self, man. Lastly, thank you for your mindset. Thank you for the way you think and bringing that mindset to this platform, Luke.

I greatly appreciate you coming on today, sir.

Luke Smitherman (22:31)

Yeah, thanks so much for having me. I’ve enjoyed it. This is my first podcast I’ve ever done, so I appreciate it.

Quentin Edmonds (22:36)

I would have never caught that at all, man. so no, absolutely, dude. you’re more than welcome, my friend. So listen, y’all heard Mr. Luke. His information is in the show notes. Please get in contact with him, connect with him. definitely make sure you’re subscribed here, because I promise you, we’re going to continue to bring up amazing people just like Mr. Luke. So, sir, I say thank you again. And everyone else, y’all have a fantastic day.

Luke Smitherman (23:00)

Thank you.

More from Real Estate Pros

All episodes →
The Investor Fuel Mastermind

Doing deals every month? Do them with people who do more.

Quarterly in-person masterminds, monthly boards and a community of serious real estate operators. Membership is by application.

Learn About Investor Fuel