Stop Lowering Your Airbnb Prices! Smarter Short-Term Rental Revenue Strategies With Andy Tompkins
Show summary
Andy Tompkins, owner of iTrip Columbus, explains how he is building a short- and midterm rental management business in a market where most owners still self-manage. Drawing on Army service and 12 years in real estate data and analytics, he shares practical lessons on pricing, winning owner trust, safety, and scaling without losing personal service. The recording continues into an extended business diagnostic covering his goals, marketing, sales process, and operations.
Key takeaways
- Build custom competitor sets for each property instead of using market-wide averages; treat lowering nightly price as a last resort, not a first reaction to low occupancy.
- Columbus, Ohio has about 4,000 short-term rental units with roughly 80% still self-managed, representing the core growth opportunity for new management operators.
- Frame the pitch to prospective owners around whether the rental is a desired second income stream or an unwanted second job, then quantify returns above the management fee plus time saved on tasks like guest Wi-Fi questions at 10pm.
- Slow down the sales process rather than mass-producing pro formas by email; present market data and revenue projections in a live 10-15 minute conversation so the information carries appropriate weight.
- Onboarding a new property typically takes one to two weeks, covering listing rebuilds, lock changes, and plugging into an existing network of cleaners and trades professionals, with no disruption to the existing listing until the new one goes live.
- Walk every property after cleaning to confirm it is guest-ready before check-in; if a mistake is discovered by the guest instead, remedy it immediately (e.g., covering a dinner while a cleaning issue is fixed).
- Treat safety as the top operational priority: audit for hazards like fireplace ash disposal and recalled amenities (e.g., pack-and-plays), since there is no outside body regulating safety in short-term rentals and the downside risk is catastrophic.
In this episode
- 00:33Meet Andy Tompkins of iTrip Columbus
- 01:37From Army Officer to Real Estate Entrepreneur
- 03:14Why Lowering Rental Prices Isn’t the Answer
- 04:29Maximizing Revenue From Empty Rental Nights
- 05:41Learning How to Win Property Owners
- 06:38Is Your Rental Income or Another Job?
- 07:24Growth Opportunities in Self-Managed Rentals
- 08:59Converting Owners to Professional Management
- 10:08Short-Term vs. Midterm Rental Strategies
- 11:34Scaling Without Losing Personal Service
- 12:25Military Leadership and Accountability
- 14:15Handling Cleaning Mistakes and Guest Complaints
- 15:17Building Trust Through Community Relationships
- 16:25Using AI to Simplify Rental Management
- 17:10Hidden Safety Risks Every Rental Owner Must Know
About the guest
Andy Tompkins owns and operates the iTrip Columbus branch, launched in March of the same year as this recording, offering full-service management for short-term and midterm rentals across the Columbus, Ohio region. He served seven years as an Army officer, including two deployments to Iraq, then spent 12 years in real estate data and analytics, including strategy and marketing analytics at JP Morgan Chase and running data operations and pricing for a single-family rental REIT that peaked at about 25,000 units nationwide.
Listen to the audio
“I don't view Columbus as a market. It's really about eight or nine sub markets that all behave differently and have different drivers of demand.”
Andy Tompkins
“The lowering the price is simple... that should be the last step that you're looking to do.”
Andy Tompkins
“Things happen outside of your span of control and they may not be your fault, but they're always your responsibility.”
Andy Tompkins
Questions answered in this episode
How should short-term rental owners decide whether to lower their nightly price when occupancy drops?
Andy Tompkins says lowering price should be the last step, not the first. He builds custom competitor sets for each property and looks at where market demand actually sits before touching price, because a property can look great but still lose bookings if a peer across the street is $100 cheaper a night.
What's the pitch for using a property manager instead of self-managing a short-term rental?
Tompkins asks owners whether the rental is a second income stream or a second job they signed up for, then shows how his management fee is offset by returns he can generate plus the time saved not handling guest messages (like Wi-Fi codes at 10pm) so owners can focus on their next deal.
How big is the self-managed short-term rental market opportunity in Columbus, Ohio?
Tompkins estimates roughly 4,000 rental units in the Columbus market, with about 80% still self-managed. He treats Columbus as eight or nine distinct submarkets with different demand drivers rather than one single market.
What changes operationally when a short-term rental shifts to a midterm (one to four month) stay?
The main differences are midstay amenity updates like linen refreshes and restocking consumables to maintain guest experience over a longer stay. iTrip's platform, built originally for vacation/short-term markets, has baseline functionality for month-long stays, and Tompkins can also build hybrid short-term/midterm programs for owners who want some revenue certainty while still capturing peak-season nightly rates.
What safety issues do self-managed short-term rental owners commonly overlook?
Tompkins points to hidden hazards like unposted fireplace/ash disposal instructions and amenities such as pack-and-plays that may be under safety recall. He argues safety has to be the top priority for operators since there's no outside body advocating for renters or owners, and the financial and reputational risk of failure is catastrophic.
How can a property management company keep a personal touch as it grows?
Tompkins says his first duty is always to delight existing owners through regular communication and availability, calling it 'the best ability is availability.' He plans to keep owner relationships personal by offloading guest communications and day-to-day operations coordination to his team while he remains the direct point of contact for owners.
Resources and links
- Investor Fuel Real Estate Mastermind
- Investor Machine Real Estate Lead Generation
- Mike on Facebook
- Mike on Instagram
- Mike on LinkedIn
- Authority Builder: Join the FREE 5-Day Challenge
- iTrip Columbus’s Website
- iTrip Net’s Website
- Andy Tompkins’ Email: andy.tompkins@itrip.net
- Andy Tompkins’ Phone Number: 614-208-8607
- iTrip Columbus on Instagram
- iTrip Columbus on Facebook
- iTrip Columbus on LinkedIn
- iTrip Columbus on X
Full transcript
Andy Tompkins (00:00)
Right. So it’s all about, what those owners’ priorities are. why did they get into this industry in the first place? Is it because they wanted to run a property or it’s because they wanted to generate a secondary stream of income? so one of the things I found very effective is like, is this a second stream of income or is this a second job that you wanted? so it being able to clearly articulate how I can generate above and beyond any management fee that I may be charging.
that there these are the additional returns you’re getting and here are all the things I’m gonna take off your plate so you can focus on that next deal rather than answering a guest communication about what the Wi-Fi code is at, ten o’clock at night.
Scott Bursey (01:08)
Welcome back to the Real Estate Pros Podcast powered by Investor Fuel. I’m your host, Scott Bursey.
Scott Bursey (01:14)
you’re
with us. Today we’re thrilled to be joined by Andy Tompkins. Andy owns an
Scott Bursey (01:19)
operates the iTrip branch.
Scott Bursey (01:21)
in Columbus, Ohio. Full service management for short-term and midterm rentals across the Columbus region. He launched in March of this year, after seven years as an Army officer and 12 years in data and analytics. His market runs about 4,000 rental units and roughly 80% of them are still self-managed.
That’s the wall he is climbing. One owner at a time. Listeners, you can expect to hear how a new operator wins owners in a market that manages itself. Real numbers on the table first and the ask for the business second. Andy, welcome to the show.
Andy Tompkins (01:57)
Scott, it’s a pleasure to be here and I’m looking forward to this conversation.
Scott Bursey (01:59)
Absolutely. It’s going to be a great conversation and Andy to help our listeners get up to speed. Please give us the ninety second highlight reel of how your career ignited and really where you’re pouring your fuel now.
Andy Tompkins (02:12)
absolutely. So I definitely have a varied and unusual career path. I had an opportunity to serve our country as an army officer for seven years, including two deployments to Iraq. and then after a couple of quick stints building houses and selling elevators, I finally figured out what I wanted to do when I grew up, and that was delving into that intersection of business intelligence and real estate. So after an opportunity to get my MBA in business intelligence and real estate, I
worked for JP Morgan Chase for a while, doing strategy and marketing analytics, and then transitioned over to a large-scale real estate investment trust that at its peak operated about 25,000 single-family rental units across the US. And I had the opportunity to own data operations and analytics for that. Everything from budgeting to pricing to optimizing our operations, and then decided to take that into my own iTrip as
a worldwide software and property management s system. And I get to I get the opportunity to blend my local understanding of the Columbus market with a best in class team behind me that handles all the IT things that the none of us want to deal with on a day to day basis.
Scott Bursey (03:11)
Wow, thanks for sharing that amazing journey, Andy. What really caught my attention about you, Andy, is the way that you lead. Market assessments, a pro forma on a specific property, safety audits on rentals you don’t manage. You hand owners real work before you even ask them for their business. Taking that a step further, talk to us about this. You spent twelve years in data and analytics.
running pricing for corporate America before you opened this market. What does that show up at the strongest level in your rental business for the first time an owner actually feels it?
Andy Tompkins (03:48)
So for me, it’s w what that time in corporate America taught me is just continuing to peel back the onion on what is going on. the easiest response if you’re operating a short-term rental is if your occupancy is down, well I need to lower my prices. so I focus on building, very custom competitor sets and understanding where market demands are.
both for properties and then other properties in my portfolio because the lowering the price is simpl that should be the last step that you’re looking to do. the competitive position for a property matters as much as the pricing. I’ve evaluated properties that look fantastic but it really doesn’t matter if the if their peer across the street is
a hundred dollars less a night. so it’s about, competitively understanding where your property fits in. And it’s not as easy as saying, well, the average property in this market does X. So that’s what my property should do. and that’s where, we were talking before about how self managed this market is in terms of domination. And a lot of people just don’t understand the ebbs and flows of
I don’t view Columbus as a market. It’s really about eight or nine sub markets that all behave differently and have different drivers of demand. So it’s about finding those pockets of demand and tapping into them.
Scott Bursey (04:55)
Andy, take a home sitting empty on a Tuesday night, for instance. Walk us through the first numbers you pull and the first change you make.
Andy Tompkins (05:04)
So again, empty on a Tuesday is not necessarily a bad thing, right? so first, the most important thing to me is understanding what the owner’s priorities are for a property. I’ve had the opportunity to talk to the full spectrum of people who, this is their home in the off season and they want high returns for the season, but they don’t want high occupancy.
So assuming that this is a property owner that’s just looking to generate the most possible revenue for their property, the first thing I’m gonna do is look at some of the leading market tools in terms of understanding growth demands and growth market demands for that specific property and where it is in the Greater Columbus area. and then, blending that with the performance I’ve seen for my own properties and driving to,
where should they be versus where they are? and then sometimes it’s having a hard conversation with an owner that if you want to be generating a specific revenue, there that there are that the competitors in the market have dictated a specific level of maybe furnishings or guest experience. And it if you want to compete at that level, then here are the changes you need to make.
Scott Bursey (06:02)
Thanks for walking us through that. Let me ask you this, Andy. Your first couple of months in this market taught you a lot of ways not to close a deal with a homeowner. What were you getting wrong in those early conversations?
Andy Tompkins (06:15)
for me it was I wasn’t valuing what I was bringing to the table enough. And I was it was too easy to give away assessments. And to we talked before, I want to be a resource, but just churning and burning through proformas, I developed a really good system of understanding market metrics and I can generate a pro forma relatively quickly.
But to me, it’s important information and it should be exchanged in a venue and a forum that matches the level of importance of the information. So even though I try to be very responsive, I want to maybe slow down those conversations just enough to give them the weight that they deserve. That it’s not a here’s an email with a PDF. It’s let’s sit and talk for 10 minutes, 15 minutes about why I’m projecting these revenues for your property.
And these specific things I could I see that you can do to improve your returns in specific markets. So it’s it was about slowing down to speed up.
Scott Bursey (07:07)
What’s the first thing you say now when an owner asks why they shouldn’t just do it themselves?
Andy Tompkins (07:13)
Right. So it’s all about, what those owners’ priorities are. why did they get into this industry in the first place? Is it because they wanted to run a property or it’s because they wanted to generate a secondary stream of income? so one of the things I found very effective is like, is this a second stream of income or is this a second job that you wanted? so it being able to clearly articulate how I can generate above and beyond any management fee that I may be charging.
that there these are the additional returns you’re getting and here are all the things I’m gonna take off your plate so you can focus on that next deal rather than answering a guest communication about what the Wi-Fi code is at, ten o’clock at night.
Scott Bursey (07:47)
Appreciate you being open about that. Walk us through this one, Andy. Most owners in your market still manage their own rentals. Right. How much room does that leave you to grow in your market?
Andy Tompkins (07:58)
Yeah, there’s a tremendous opportunity for growth. and especially as I th I see a lot of units migrating to a midterm rental framework, with that one to four month stay. there are some good operators in the Columbus market. most of them are kind of tapped out with where they want to be in terms of their unit count and their growth. so for me it’s very education heavy and helping owners understand
both, the time commitments and how much I can save them, but also, the biggest thing that I learned, I’ve been learning over the last couple of months is about safety and how all the hidden dangers in that rental property expose you to, financial and reputational harm. so there’s just a lot of things that self-managed property owner just doesn’t think about on a day-to-day basis, especially if it’s their home that they’ve since converted
i they’ve lived in it so long that you just kind of get blind to some of the concerns that a fresh perspective gives you in that case.
Scott Bursey (08:48)
When one of those owners finally gets tired of doing it all themselves, what’s the first thing you put in front of them?
Andy Tompkins (09:33)
Yeah, so I know after we walk through, what my expectations would be for that property in terms of generating revenue, yeah, I walk through my owner’s agreement, which at least I feel is pretty fair to both parties. I’m not looking to lock some up into a long term agreement. If you’re not happy with me, then you shouldn’t be working with me. but at the same time, it’s clearly lays out here’s what I’m gonna do for you on a monthly, daily basis throughout the term of this agreement.
and then the onboarding process is pretty straightforward. it should take me less than a week to two weeks to re unfortunately I need to rebuild the listing for the owner in this case. but switching over locks. I have a network of cleaners and trades professionals that I’m already working with. So it’s more just about deciding which is the best fit for that specific property and getting them, keyed up and
Again, one of the advantages I have is being part of the iThirp family is there’s an integrated hub where I can make all that magic happen and the end result is no disruption for the existing listing until I’m ready to step mine to set mine in place and carry it forward in the future.
Scott Bursey (10:32)
Andy, wondering. iTrip systems were built for short term rentals. Right. What has to change in how a stay runs when a guest stays weeks instead of just on the weekends?
Andy Tompkins (10:42)
Yeah, the biggest difference is, offering, midstay amenity updates. So whether that be, midstay linen refreshes or restocking consumables, and it’s all just a part of making sure that per the person i in enjoying that stay just continues to have that same level of quality and care throughout what could be, a month, two month long endeavor. So iTrip
It started in vacation markets. So there is some base functionality in month-long plus stays, especially some of the markets where you snow say the snowburger community that lives in Ohio and has a vacation home in Florida, they rent that out as a vacation home in the summer and then they personally stay there or they rent a property for multiple months in the winter. So iTrip, even though the crux of the business that they do and that I do is short-term rentals.
There is that baseline flex baseline structure. but then the other thing I love about what I’m able to offer at iTrip is I have flexibility as the local owner operator to custom fit a specific program that fits your property. So for example, say you wanted a little bit of cost certainty or revenue certainty, but you don’t want to miss those peak events where you’re gonna generating large nightly rental rates. We can develop a hybrid midterm, short-term
program for your property. And I could do that because I because it’s my company to run.
Scott Bursey (11:56)
Thanks for taking us inside that. Andy, your owners hired a person, not a company. Right. What happens to that when you grow? How are you planning on keeping the personal touch?
Andy Tompkins (12:08)
Yeah, I think my first duty is always going to be continuing to delight my existing owners, right? And that comes through regular communication and being of being available. I mentioned before the best available best ability is availability. So being there when my existing property owners need to call me or need to get a hold of me. and what I like about this structure that I’m building here is that
The first things that I take off my plate are things like guest communications or operations coordination. So I will always maintain that connection with my property owners because again, that’s the core of what I’m doing is I’m meeting a need first and foremost for that investor or that property owner.
Scott Bursey (12:45)
Let’s talk about this, Andy. Seven years as an army officer came before the analytics years. Right. What did those years teach you about accountability that you apply to your business iTrip currently?
Andy Tompkins (12:59)
Yeah. So for me, accountability isn’t something, I read in a leadership book. It was something that was ingrained to me first. at West Point, you go through the process of learning how to be led before you can lead, right? so understanding that things happen outside of your span of control and they may not be your fault, but they’re always your responsibility. So what am I going to do to remedy this situation to the best of my ability?
and that’s the one of the biggest things, as an officer I learned again is that things happen and there are things I can control and there are things I can’t. All the things I can control, I better have a pretty good plan for controlling those things, for mitigating risks. but then no matter what happens, we used to say in the army, can develop a great plan, but the enemy always gets a vote. And I don’t know that there are a lot of enemies in this space, but there are certainly things that are outside our control, whether it be
an FAA shutdown or weather conditions. So I have a specific plan to control and mitigate the risk as much as possible on my things. but it’s about showing up every day. It’s about being disciplined in the daily thing
That we need to do. And it’s about taking responsibility and finding a path forward no matter what obstacle you may come across.
Scott Bursey (14:04)
Owning the results is your phrase for it. When a cleaning gets missed and a guest is unhappy, let’s say, what does owning it look like at your shop?
Andy Tompkins (14:49)
Well, first owning it is knowing that work order wasn’t completed prior to that guest check-in. So it’s one thing for a guest to be notified that there’s a problem before they walk in that door, but it and it’s an entirely different type of failing if the guest is the one that discovers that cleaning didn’t occur. so that’s one of the disciplines we have in my company is that myself or a member of my team walks every single property.
after the clean to make sure it is guess ready for that next person to walk through the door. but to me owning that sort of mistake is quickly remedying it. And you for example, say they’re checking in three o’clock on a Friday, can I take care of their dinner, get a get them a nice dinner while that cleaner’s in there, fixing a problem. Because maybe it wasn’t the whole clean was missed. Maybe
mistakes happen, someone missed a room or, didn’t clean a bathroom. I don’t wanna have to have the renters there while we’re taking care of that issue. Is there something I can do to help them have a nice evening on me while that issue is being resolved?
Scott Bursey (15:43)
Thanks for that breakdown. Andy, when it comes to relationships and networking, talk to us about the relationships that carry your business today.
Andy Tompkins (15:51)
Yeah, y and i we’ve talked about it a couple different times at this point, Scott, but to me it’s about being a resource first and foremost. so I’ve been involved in my community service is not something that stopped for me after I took off the uniform. I’m the commander of my VFW post in Westerville, Ohio, as a suburb of Columbus, member of our Sunrise Rotary Club, active in major events that we’re doing in the community.
and then I’ve been a member of I’ve been a board member for the Ohio Veterans Hall of Fame Foundation for about 12 years now. All of those are just a continuation of service and being present in my community and giving back. it’s a lot easier to trust someone with information if you’ve already seen them to be a trustworthy part of the community. So being present first and foremost in as many venues as possible without asking for something.
is to me the bedrock of all that.
Scott Bursey (16:36)
And that’s a strong circle to be a part of.
Andy Tompkins (16:39)
Yeah. It but again, it’s about service first. And if business comes out of it, great, but it’s about the service.
Scott Bursey (16:45)
It really is, serving people first. That’s outstanding. Andy, let’s dive deep. Say an owner across town is managing their own rental tonight, doing every job themselves. What is the first move that you would teach them?
Andy Tompkins (16:59)
So for someone that is committed to just continuing to operate something themselves, I would want them to understand maybe some of the AI obviously is both a buzzword and it’s a pr tremendous opportunity at the same
time so or developing tools themselves that help with their friction points. So whether it be guest communications, whether it be automated instructions for upcoming guests or checkout and reminders helping that owner understand some of the things that they can do to just kind of prolong the life of operating it themselves.
Scott Bursey (17:29)
Thank you for that perspective. And Andy, you have given our listeners a tremendous amount of perspective today regarding your niche. But is there any additional words of advice or a golden nugget that you like to leave with our listeners?
Andy Tompkins (17:43)
I touched on it before with safety, and I think that is one of the biggest things that the short-term, midterm rental market in general omits and doesn’t pay anywhere near enough attention to. There is really no one advocating on our behalf. and as a result, the onus is on us as operators, whether it’s your in an individual property or whether you’re a management company, to make sure that safety is not
an afterthought and it’s not second or third on the list. It has to be first. There are just so many opportunities to fail. And then the risks of failure in the safety space are catastrophic. So you may not love having a warning sign with a QR code next to the fireplace in your unit.
The risks of something bad happening versus that offset of a small warning sign to give instructions on how where to dispose of ashes. or the you may think you’re doing the right thing by providing a pack and play as a as an amenity for your property. But when’s the last time you looked and saw if there was a recall on that pack and play? Are you potentially introducing a risk into the property that you shouldn’t? So
I if investors take anything from this today, I hope it’s a renewed focus and emphasis on the safety, the safe operation of their units.
Scott Bursey (18:57)
Great words right there. Andy, for those of our listeners that want to keep this conversation moving, stay in your lane, perhaps collaborate with you on future deals, what’s the best way for them to plug into your pipeline and reach you directly?
Andy Tompkins (19:09)
Yeah, the easiest way to reach me directly, my email is just Andy. Tompkins at itrip.net. and my personal cell, which I carry with me all the time, is 614-208-8607. And then they can also go to columbus.itrip.co and there’s a portal there to reach out directly to as a potential partner or property owner.
Scott Bursey (19:29)
Andy, thank you so much for joining us today on the Real Estate Pros podcast.
Andy Tompkins (19:33)
Thank It was a pleasure. And I hope again, if they didn’t take anything else from this, I hope you the listeners are will take a renewed eye towards the safety the safe operation of their properties.
Scott Bursey (19:42)
This has been an absolute pleasure. And to our listeners, we appreciate you. If you receive value from today’s episode, please subscribe. We’ll be fueling your tanks with a lineup of elite guests, just like Andy Tompkins, who are accelerating and setting the pace for the rest of the industry. Until next time, keep your standards high and your vision clear. We’ll see you in the next episode, everyone.
Andy Tompkins (20:05)
Thank you.