← Real Estate Pros
Real Estate Pros · November 16, 2026 · 17 min listen

How to Build a NYC Real Estate Business on Referrals and Trust | Karen Feldman

With Karen Feldman

Show summary

Karen Feldman, a New York City residential agent working both rentals and sales, explains how she built her business on transparency and referrals after starting in 2019, just before COVID. She shares why you hire the agent and not the agency, how a rent-versus-buy calculator turns renters into future buyers, and why she says the best time to buy is when interest rates are higher.

Key takeaways

  • Karen's rule on timing: buy when rates are higher because prices drop; you can refinance later for about $3,000 if rates fall, versus bidding wars and overpaying when rates are low.
  • She sends every rental client a buy-versus-rent calculator immediately after closing, which factors in down payment loss, interest cost, and interest rates to show savings over 5, 10, 15, and 20 years.
  • 90 to 95 percent of her business comes from relationships and referrals; she avoids cold calling and relies on past clients sending her the people closest to them.
  • In Manhattan, about 75% of the market is co-ops, which require specific debt-to-income ratios and post-closing liquidity (PCL), with down payments ranging from 20% to 50% depending on the building.
  • New agents evaluating a first firm should ask whether the company provides leads, how much training it offers, and whether there is a mentor program.
  • Save money from commission checks and plan for tax: a $30,000 check requires giving roughly 30% to the government since it's pre-tax income, and real estate income is inconsistent month to month.
  • She has navigated two company mergers in six years and tells clients the agent relationship carries over regardless of which agency name is on the door.

In this episode

  1. 00:00Why Higher Rates Can Help Buyers
  2. 01:03Meet Karen Feldman
  3. 02:06Turning Leads Into Lifelong Clients
  4. 03:04Why Transparency Wins Referrals
  5. 03:44Build Trust on the Client’s Timeline
  6. 05:02You’re Hiring the Agent, Not Agency
  7. 06:31Why Past Clients Are the Opportunity
  8. 07:07Rent vs. Buy in New York
  9. 09:15Higher Rates, Lower Prices?
  10. 11:05Choosing Your First Brokerage
  11. 11:26Save Your Commission Checks
  12. 12:0190–95% Relationship-Driven Business
  13. 12:41Preparing Renters to Become Buyers
  14. 14:09Why Karen Still Says Buy
  15. 15:22Communication & Responsiveness Win

About Karen Feldman

Karen Feldman is a residential real estate agent in New York City working both rentals and sales. She comes from a sales career with family roots in commercial real estate but chose residential because she wanted to work directly with people. She started in the industry in 2019, right before COVID hit, and has worked through two company mergers in six years at boutique agencies.

Listen to the audio

“My immediate answer is when you're ready. The second answer is actually when interest rates are higher.”

Karen Feldman

“You're hiring the agent, not the agency.”

Karen Feldman

“The educated consumer is the best customer.”

Karen Feldman

“My apartment would rent for $7,000. And I'm paying $1,600 a month. It's an amazing opportunity.”

Karen Feldman
New York City real estateresidential salesrentalsreferral-based businessbuy vs rent calculatorco-op financinginterest ratesclient relationshipsnew agent advice

Questions answered in this episode

When is the best time to buy real estate according to Karen Feldman?

Her first answer is whenever the buyer is personally ready. Her second answer is when interest rates are higher, because prices drop in response, and if rates fall later you can refinance for roughly $3,000. Buying when rates are low puts you in bidding wars against more buyers and risks overpaying.

What is the difference between hiring an agent and hiring an agency?

Karen says every agency has access to the same listings and tools, so the real choice is the individual agent. She works at boutique agencies specifically so clients get one-on-one attention instead of being 'a tiny fish' lost in a large company.

How does Karen turn rental clients into future home buyers?

After closing a rental, she immediately sends the client a buy-versus-rent calculator that factors in down payment loss, interest, and interest rates, showing savings over 5, 10, 15, and 20 years. She says this isn't about pushing them to buy immediately, it's about getting them educated and 'pre-ready' before they're ready to act.

What financial requirements are unique to buying in New York City co-ops?

Karen says about 75% of the Manhattan market is co-ops, which require specific debt-to-income ratios and post-closing liquidity (PCL) requirements, not just a down payment and pre-approval letter. Down payments can range from 20% to 50% depending on the building, and each building has different requirements.

What should a new real estate agent look for in their first brokerage?

Karen advises checking whether the company provides leads, how much training they offer, and whether they have a mentor program. She chose a firm that trained her properly and fed her leads because she didn't want to ask friends for business, and she turned those company leads into lifetime clients and referrals.

How much of Karen's business comes from referrals versus marketing?

She estimates 90 to 95 percent of her business depends on relationships and word of mouth. She says she is 'mostly a gatherer' once someone works with her, since clients come back to her for life or refer her to people in other states or countries.

Resources and links

Full transcript

Karen Feldman (00:00)

But it’s funny, everyone always asks me when is the best time to buy? My immediate answer is when you’re ready. The second answer is actually when interest rates are higher.

when interest rates are higher, prices go down, and if rates ever do come down again you can refinance, it’s three thousand dollars about.

And you’ve gotten that price lower. If you wait till rates are low, you’re competing with everyone. That’s when you get into bidding wars, overpay for a home.

Scott Bursey (01:03)

Welcome back to the Real Estate Pros podcast powered by Investor Fuel. I’m your host, Scott Bursey Glad you’re with us.

Scott Bursey (01:11)

And today we’re pleased to be joined by Karen Feldman. Karen is a residential agent in New York City, working both rentals and sales. She comes from a career in sales with family roots in commercial real estate. She chose residential because she wanted to work with people. Karen started in 2019 and she’s built her business the patient way. Never rushing a client, always working on their time frame.

Today her clients send her the people they care about most. Listeners, get ready for some valuable insight on what it takes to build a business on patience in the New York City market. One

Scott Bursey (01:50)

Referral.

Scott Bursey (01:51)

at a time. Karen, welcome to the show.

Karen Feldman (01:53)

Thank you so much for having me.

Scott Bursey (01:54)

It is wonderful having you here and to help our listeners get up to speed. Please give us the ninety second highlight reel of how your career ignited and where you’re pouring your fuel now.

Karen Feldman (02:06)

My career started in this industry in 2019 and got hit with COVID in 2020, so that really put a damper, but it got ignited. I chose the right firm, which trained me to do everything properly. They fed me leads because I don’t like to ask friends for business, and I turned those company leads into lifetime

clients and referrals.

Scott Bursey (02:32)

Wow. Thank you for sharing that with us. And you know what really caught my attention about you, Karen, is the way you work with your clients. You never force anything. You never rush people. You stay on their time frame, not yours. That kind of patience is rare. And taking that a step further, your past clients send you the people closest to them. That’s where your business comes from now.

What is it about the way you work with a client that makes them send you the people they care about most?

Karen Feldman (03:04)

the biggest compliment that I keep getting from my past clients is I’m transparent. They feel that I am putting their needs above my own. And there’s nothing shifty about me. Real estate agents have the worst reputation of being sleazy. And everyone’s like, You had my interest at heart.

You fed me information, you advised, you didn’t push, but only if it was the best deal possible. You pushed a little, but you took my no. And I just am lucky enough that I can do that.

Scott Bursey (03:39)

Where does that trust get built? Early on or somewhere along the way?

Karen Feldman (03:44)

Well, you have to build it at all times. I start off with every client who’s a referral or company based client with a nice long conversation if they want that. I explain how I work in both rentals and sales, what they can expect from me, and I always ask what they’re looking for in an agent as well, because it is about them.

Every single person works differently and wants to be talked to differently. So I listen to what they’re saying instead of trying to constantly pitch myself in the beginning. Then my transparency comes in. As we’re starting to work, I let them know everything. This is why this is great. I let them know recent sales and I do an in depth

market report on every deal. So they get to feel that they’re as educated as me.

And then just holding their hand whenever there’re some people who want their hand held every minute of the day and there are other people who just give them the updates once a week.

Work as they request, not how you want to.

Scott Bursey (04:48)

Thanks for laying that out for us. Curious to know, Karen, you’ve been through two mergers now. Each time the company changed, your name had to start over again. What does that do to the business that you’ve built?

Karen Feldman (05:02)

When I tell anyone who I’m working with or go potentially working with, every agency has these same abilities. You’re hiring the agent, not the agency. So huge difference. And again, my careers have been with more boutique agencies. So I tell them you’re getting

one on one, you’re not dealing with a huge monster and getting put into huge pond and you’re a tiny fish. Here you’re being treated as the only fish.

So two mergers in six years. It’s been interesting.

Scott Bursey (06:16)

Thank you for the detail on that, Karen. And talk to us about this. All of your work is in New York, a market you call a different beast from anywhere else in the country. What do you feel is the biggest opportunity in your market right now?

Karen Feldman (06:31)

As I said I work in rentals and sales. I like the combination because when one is slow the other still have incoming income.

The biggest opportunity would be reaching out to past clients because these people already trust you. I don’t like cold calling. I don’t like doing this. The biggest opportunity is reaching out to my past clients were successful with me because word of mouth is the best advertisement.

Scott Bursey (06:58)

If you could walk us through this, Karen. What does a renter look like today when they’re getting close to buying with you down the road?

Karen Feldman (07:07)

When I work with a renter, I get to see basics of their financials. Because we have New York, you can’t just hand over your social security. You have to hand over six pieces of financial information. I just closed a ten thousand dollar rental. I then immediately send them a buy versus rent calculator.

So they can play around with it. They can see what the benefit of buying is. I always tell somebody if you’re living somewhere for one or two, three years, don’t buy; rent But if you’re gonna be somewhere five years plus, buy because the monthlies are your rent and they’re a quarter of what rent is. You get back the purchase price, you get back all that. So

It shows you the money you’re saving over five, ten, fifteen, twenty years, and it’s very comprehensive. It takes into account the loss of your down payment money, the loss of interest on that. It takes into account the interest rate. It takes into account all different factors so you can really see if it’s a benefit or if it’s not.

But I send that to all my rental clients. And it’s not me pushing them to buy tomorrow, it’s getting them pre ready before they’re even ready.

Scott Bursey (09:02)

Switching gears here just a little bit. You got your start right as COVID hit. So you watch this market change fast, more than once. What do you watch closest in a market like New York?

Karen Feldman (09:15)

I watch interest rates, I watch the stock market, and I watch market inventory as well.

But it’s funny, everyone always asks me when is the best time to buy? My immediate answer is when you’re ready. The second answer is actually when interest rates are higher.

when interest rates are higher, prices go down, and if rates ever do come down again you can refinance, it’s three thousand dollars about.

And you’ve gotten that price lower. If you wait till rates are low, you’re competing with everyone. That’s when you get into bidding wars, overpay for a home.

And then when you go to sell, say it’s a million-dollar apartment during higher interest rates, you can get that for 900 to 910. Now, when interest rates are low, you’re gonna be paying one million for that same apartment.

And then when you go to sell, you have less of a profit margin, if any. So it’s about if they’re ready and they have the down payment. But in New York, as I said, it’s a different beast. You also are dealing with 75% of the market being co ops, where you have to have certain financial requirements, certain debt to income ratios, certain PCL post closing liquidity. So it’s not just I have my 10% down.

I have my pre-approval letter, I’m ready to buy. No, that’s a condo or anywhere else in the world. Manhattan, it could be anywhere from twenty percent down to fifty percent down deposit. Each building is different. And then you also have the other financial requirements you have to meet.

Scott Bursey (10:52)

Thanks for the honest look at that. Karen, you started this later in life at a small firm you chose so you could learn. What should a new agent look for in a first firm?

Karen Feldman (11:05)

What they’re providing them, are they providing them company leads? Some companies you are just thrown into the deep end and swim or not. how much training are they providing you? Do they have a mentor program to learn from other people?

Scott Bursey (11:22)

What do you wish someone had told you back in two thousand nineteen?

Karen Feldman (11:26)

I knew, but I wish more people talked about it. Save your money. Real estate is ebbs and flows. You get a thirty thousand dollar check, you might not get another one for eight months. You have to be smart about preparing your financing and not just enjoy that thirty thousand dollar check where you also have to give thirty percent to the government because it’s pre-tax and

Don’t get too excited over one big chat.

Scott Bursey (11:54)

And Karen, as far as networking goes, how much of your business runs on relationships compared to marketing?

Karen Feldman (12:01)

I’d say ninety to ninety five percent depends on my relationships. I’ve talked to people I am mostly a gatherer once you work with me. You are working with me for a lifetime, whether it be here or asking for a referral in another state or country. But I do need to spend more time hunting for business, but I have always been an organic person.

I like things to happen organically.

Scott Bursey (12:28)

Love hearing how those relationships came together. Karen, picture a person renting in New York right now, dreaming about owning a home there one day. What is the first move you would teach them?

Karen Feldman (12:41)

Make sure your credit is on point.

It will help you with your interest rate and it will also get you approved by a co op. You have a bad credit, you’re dead in the water.

put some money aside from each paycheck. I’m not saying you have to put aside a ton, but also be ready to buy. know what you want. What are your must haves versus your wants? And is that feasible?

And pick your neighborhood ’cause each neighborhood is very different.

And know what your monthly all in. you’re paying six thousand a month in rent. Is that what you want to be spending monthly, including mortgage maintenance or monthlies? Be educated yourself. That’s why the second I work close the renter, I send them the rent versus buy calculator just so they can start educating themselves. I will actually meet with somebody who’s not even ready to buy for four years and just

Talk with them. Information is free. And I’m going to date myself. the educated consumer is the best customer. So I like to spend time with people way before they’re even ready. And they’re like, I don’t want to waste your time. I’m like, it’s a half an hour. Let’s talk. Let’s go over things.

You’re not wasting my time.

Scott Bursey (13:54)

Thank you for covering that ground with us, Karen. And Karen, you have given us some pinpoint perspective on the New York market today. But is there any additional words, golden nugget or two that you’d like to leave with our listeners?

Karen Feldman (14:09)

Personally, buy. It’s an investment, especially right now. I bought my home twenty four years ago and I watched the monthlies. I now live in a beautiful building in a huge one bedroom for under sixteen hundred a month, including everything cable.

Wi-Fi, electric. If you’re going to be somewhere, you’re not putting away. It’s an investment. And I’m now living this. My apartment would rent for $7,000. And I’m paying $1,600 a month. It’s an amazing opportunity. I was expecting to be out of here and moving something bigger, but I didn’t get married. So this is still big enough for me, but

I’m living in a beautiful doorman elevator building on the Upper East Side for sixteen hundred a month, including utilities, everything. Buy it’s an investment and it will pay off.

Scott Bursey (15:08)

Appreciate those words. And Karen, for those of our listeners that want to keep this conversation moving, stay in your lane, collaborate with you perhaps. What is the best way for them to plug into your pipeline and reach you directly?

Karen Feldman (15:22)

It’s best to text me or email me. I will answer usually within twenty minutes. And if I’m out with a client, I’ll just say, Hey, I’m out with the client. Can I talk to you after six today? Communication and responsiveness is key. If you text me at two AM in the morning, which some of my clients do because they’re in Europe.

I won’t respond until the next morning. Sorry, you gotta give me a little bit of sleep. But just let somebody know you’re working on something and that you received their question.

Scott Bursey (15:54)

Karen, thank you for joining us today on the Real Estate Pros podcast. This has been just a pleasure speaking with you.

Karen Feldman (16:02)

Thank you so much for having me. I enjoyed this as well. And I hope somebody learned something. If they want to work with me, great if they want to work with somebody else. it is the biggest investment of your life. You have to work with somebody you feel comfortable with.

Scott Bursey (16:18)

And to our listeners, we appreciate each and every one of you. If you receive value from today’s episode, please subscribe. We’ll be fueling your tanks with a lineup of elite guests, just like Karen Feldman, who are accelerating and setting the pace for the rest of the industry. Until next time, keep your standards high and your vision clear. We’ll see you on the next episode, everyone.

More from Real Estate Pros

All episodes →
The Investor Fuel Mastermind

Doing deals every month? Do them with people who do more.

Quarterly in-person masterminds, monthly boards and a community of serious real estate operators. Membership is by application.

Learn About Investor Fuel