How One Sober Living Rental Generates $6,000/Month | Micah Shelton’s Real Estate Strategy
Show summary
Oregon-based investor and firefighter Micah Shelton explains how a co-living renovation became a hands-off Sober Living Rental, with an operator leasing the property and managing residents. He shares practical details on occupancy rules, renovations, DSCR financing, underwriting and due diligence, then discusses out-of-state investing and assessing fire-damaged homes.
Key takeaways
- A single sober living house leased to an operating company can generate $6,000/month on a triple-net-style structure where the operator pays taxes, utilities, and day-to-day damage, while the owner covers big capex like roofs and major plumbing.
- Converting a 4-bedroom home into an 8-bedroom co-living home mainly requires framing new walls with doors in existing living/game/dining rooms that already have windows; below-grade basements requiring new egress windows (cutting concrete, digging window wells) add significant complexity and cost.
- DSCR loans are underwritten off projected market rent, not personal income; Micah's $4,500/month projected rent at about 7.25% interest qualified him to borrow $625,000, setting his target all-in budget for purchase plus a $100,000-$125,000 renovation.
- Occupancy limits for unrelated adults vary drastically by jurisdiction — most areas allow only 4-5 people, but Micah's Clackamas County, Oregon allows up to 16, which is why an East Coast sober living company chose to expand into that specific market.
- Underwriters can be hesitant about commercial leases on residential DSCR loans; Micah worked around this by getting a personal lease guarantee from a company owner plus first month's deposit before transitioning the lease to the company name.
- Out-of-state investing in Indiana offered home prices of $60,000-$125,000 renting for $1,200-$1,500/month, hitting roughly the 1% rule, with some properties appreciating from the $60,000-$70,000 range up to $150,000 since COVID.
- For fire-damaged properties, get a structural engineer and contractor to assess before underwriting; smoke damage often requires replacing sheetrock, flooring, wiring, and PVC/PEX plumbing, making true renovation costs far higher than they appear on the surface.
In this episode
- 00:00Meet Micah Shelton: Firefighter and Investor
- 00:27How a Co-Living Deal Became Sober Living
- 01:59Converting a 4-Bedroom House Into 8 Bedrooms
- 03:54Renovation Challenges and Egress Windows
- 05:15Leasing to a Professional Sober Living Operator
- 07:26Occupancy Rules and Shared Housing Regulations
- 10:34Breaking Down the $6,000 Monthly Rental Deal
- 13:11Using DSCR Loans to Finance Sober Living
- 15:06How to Vet Sober Living Operators
- 18:02Investing Out of State and Building Local Teams
- 20:12Using Rental Income to Fund Retirement
- 22:37House Hacking and Real Estate for Beginners
- 24:31Finding Opportunity in Distressed Properties
- 25:48Renovating Fire-Damaged Properties
- 26:53Expanding the Sober Living Portfolio
About the guest
Micah Shelton is an Oregon-based real estate investor and firefighter in the Portland metro area. He started with single-family and duplex rentals and out-of-state properties in Indiana, then moved into house flipping and co-living conversions, and now operates a sober living rental leased to an East Coast-based operating company, with a second sober living property under renovation and three more planned for 2025.
Listen to the audio
“So with my first project, we're getting $6,000 a month from the company, but it's similar to a triple net lease where they're paying the taxes, they're paying the utilities.”
Micah Shelton
“Our passion as investors is owning real estate, owning the homes and having a nice property that's appreciating. And I think the two can go hand in hand. It's just doing a little due diligence.”
Micah Shelton
“Think of all the wires that got melted. You're probably gonna have to rewire the whole house.”
Micah Shelton
Questions answered in this episode
How does a sober living rental lease work compared to a normal rental?
Micah structured his first sober living deal like a triple net lease: the operating company pays him $6,000 a month and also covers taxes, utilities, and day-to-day damage. He retains responsibility for big capital expenditures like a roof or major plumbing, and his lease allows him to walk the property every six months to assess wear and tear.
How do you convert a 4-bedroom house into an 8-bedroom co-living home?
Micah framed new walls with doors in existing living rooms, game rooms, and offices to create bedrooms, provided the spaces already had windows for egress. His first house was harder because the lower level was a below-grade walkout basement, requiring digging window wells, cutting concrete, and meeting code requirements on window height and size for legal egress.
How do occupancy rules affect co-living and sober living deals?
Occupancy limits for non-related adults in a single-family home vary widely by city and county; most areas allow only 4-5 people, but Micah's area in Clackamas County, Oregon allows up to 16. Companies like PadSplit get around tighter limits by making all occupants members of the PadSplit community, legally making them 'related' through that membership agreement.
How does DSCR financing work for a co-living or sober living rental?
A DSCR (debt service coverage ratio) loan is based on market rent for the property rather than personal income; the lender takes the projected monthly rent and reverse-engineers the loan amount. In Micah's case, a $4,500/month market rent at roughly 7.25% interest qualified him to borrow $625,000, which became his target all-in cost (purchase plus renovation) for the refinance.
What should investors check before buying rental property out of state?
Micah recommends physically visiting the market for a few days (spending $500-$1,000) to drive the neighborhoods, interviewing multiple property managers via Zoom before the trip, then touring their managed properties and other homes for sale in person. He also advises vetting the property manager's network of electricians, plumbers, and maintenance contacts before buying.
What should investors look for when underwriting a fire-damaged property?
Micah stresses bringing in a structural engineer and contractor before assuming the extent of damage, since fire can look bad on the surface but be structurally sound, or look minor but hide major smoke damage. He notes that wiring, PVC/PEX plumbing, sheetrock, and flooring are often compromised and need full replacement or encapsulation products, making renovation costs potentially much higher than a standard rehab.
Resources and links
- Investor Fuel Real Estate Mastermind
- Investor Machine Real Estate Lead Generation
- Mike on Facebook
- Mike on Instagram
- Mike on LinkedIn
- Authority Builder: Join the FREE 5-Day Challenge
- Micah Shelton’s BiggerPockets
- Micah Shelton on Facebook
Full transcript
Micah Shelton (00:00)
So with my first project, we’re getting $6,000 a month from the company, but it’s similar to a triple net lease where they’re paying the taxes, they’re paying the utilities.
They’re doing any damage that happens. you have more wear and tear on the home for sure. So in our lease, it’s specified that I get to walk the property every six months, and we can go over if there’s extra wear and tear and extra damage, that does fall on the company to assess and address. your big CapEx expenditures, that’s going to fall on me as the homeowner.
Dylan Silver (01:01)
Hey folks, welcome back to the show. Today we’re joined by Micah Shelton, Oregon based investor and firefighter, currently working on a Sober Living Deal. Micah, thanks for joining us today.
Micah Shelton (01:12)
Yeah, glad to be here.
Dylan Silver (01:13)
Sober Living, big interest in this and we were talking in the green room. there’s so much behind Co-Living spaces and Sober Living and different ways where investors are getting active in different asset classes. How did this deal come across your desk?
Micah Shelton (01:28)
Yeah, was going down the Co-Living route. I had flipped homes in the past. I have a handful of rentals here in the Portland area. we’ve had rentals out of state as well, and we really fell in love with the Co-Living model. We thought the numbers, mapped out to make a single family resident cash flow long term. And so my goal was to have a handful of Co-Living homes as I get closer to retirement. That was gonna help fund my retirement.
going forward as far as real estate goes, and got the home fully furnished, ready to go. We’d been working with Pad Split. they had set up a branch on the West Coast. And so they actually flew up a rep to tour our home and shoot video on it. and while we were placing people into the home, a Sober Living company reached out and said, Would you mind if we came and looked at the property? We might want to rent some rooms. So they came and toured it and said,
Can we rent the whole thing? so that opened up a discussion on what that looks like, renting to a company. And ultimately, for me, it was a win-win because now I don’t have to deal with the tenants. They have their own tenants, they’re bringing the tenants in, they’re managing those folks, they’re paying me a premium for the rents. and they took over pretty much every aspect of the home other than the capital expenditure. So hopefully establishing a long-term relationship with.
this company here locally. And then I’m already working on house number two for them. So we can get into that as well as if you’d like.
Dylan Silver (02:45)
Sober Living, there’s so much to unpack there. And before we dive in head first there, I wanna walk through the genesis of getting into Co-Living. And were you Co-Living always or did you start in, single family, one tenant, long term leases?
Micah Shelton (03:00)
Yeah, I started as duplexes, single family and duplexes. We bought a handful of properties out in Indiana, which I did because I had a buddy from the fire department that moved out there and we were buying homes out there and managing them remotely. I sold those projects, ended up buying some single family and duplexes here in the Portland area. We were flipping houses before that, so that’s where it started and morphed into keeping these homes as rentals.
When we started crunching the numbers on what we were cash flowing on our duplexes, it wasn’t great. We had great properties that would appreciate over time. But if you’re in it for cash flow on some level, generally the numbers aren’t where you’d like them to be. And so running the numbers on Co-Living, we started to say, hey, this looks like a really viable model that we can have a nice appreciating asset that is cash flowing as well. So the
First property we did, bought it from a wholesaler. So it was a four-bedroom, three-bath house. If you’re familiar with split level homes, this was a split level home that was never built with a garage. So the lower level was a bonus room, a game room, and an office. We converted all that into habitable space by adding egress windows. so we basically took the four-bedroom home and turned it in ultimately into an eight-bedroom home, utilizing the upstairs living room as well.
the Sober Living home that ended up taking over that property converted that living room back into a communal space. So now it’s a seven bedroom, three bath house, shared living room, kitchen, dining room area. So yeah, worked out really good.
Dylan Silver (04:24)
How intensive is it to take a four-bed into an eight-bed? Is this something where someone with some level of knowledge swinging a hammer can do this themselves? Obviously, when you’re talking about adding windows, there’s a degree of complexity there, converting a garage into livable space. But is this something where, if you haven’t done this before, you really gotta have your ducks in the row? Or could a new investor, a new rehabber
get into a Co-Living deal and go from four to eight bedrooms.
Micah Shelton (04:54)
Yeah, I really think it depends. I think the right house is gonna need very minimal skill set. So if you can swing a hammer, you know how to frame a wall, that sort of thing. So you think of a home that’s got a formal living room, a formal dining room, maybe some kind of living room, game room type space. If those have adequate windows, well, you’re in good shape because all you need to do is frame walls with doors.
Now you have your two egresses, which is a requirement if you’re gonna have people sleep in those rooms. the house that I did was a little more difficult because the lower level was below grade, so it’s under the ground, like a basement would be. It’s like a walkout basement, but the backside is all under dirt. So you have to dig out a window well, cutting that concrete can be a little challenging. you got to get the right tools for that, and then knowing how to frame that window so it’s not gonna leak and things like that. And there’s codes.
in every community on heights that window has to be off the floor, how big the window has to be. So there’s a little more involved if that’s the style of home you’re going for. But there’s some great videos out there of Co-Living folks like myself that have converted homes very minimally if the house is set up correctly from the beginning.
Dylan Silver (06:00)
Now I wanna dive into Sober Living, right? You’re in an interesting deal structure where you own the Sober Living, but you’re not going to be in charge of the day to day. Is that common or typically do the folks that are operating also own the property itself?
Micah Shelton (06:16)
there’s both. So I’ve met some owner operators for sure. Definitely more hands-on with your clients, the folks that are coming and going. I got fortunate enough to meet with a company that is in growth mode and they’re looking for the right homes that fit their clientele. slightly higher end, home to provide a better product, a better living environment.
They want to manage the people. They want to manage what they’re good at. They didn’t want to buy and renovate the homes. And ultimately they do want to own the home from me. So that is part of our lease agreement that they have the first right of refusal to buy the home. They’re putting a business in there. They’re getting that established. They want to maintain that. They don’t want me to turn around and decide to change my mind and sell it to somebody else or do something else with it. So that was a negotiating thing we did. So they did a three-year
With a lease option to buy at any point during that three years. I’ve already talked to them about extending that three years out even farther. So more homes for them, let’s keep them renting. I get the cash flow, I get the appreciation. We keep setting the bar a little higher on the purchase price. it’s a win for me. And ultimately I don’t have to manage the people, which I didn’t want to do. So I feel like it’s a really good model.
if you just want to be the homeowner, you’re the investor, and you want to own and manage a home and cash flow and have an appreciating asset, these companies are in need right now. There’s not enough homes to support the community. And it’s not just Sober Living. I think we had talked about it before too. There’s homes for sheltering women that are in need, maybe with families. there’s veteran homes. you get into the Sober Living, then you go into Co-Living. There’s even Co-Living for seniors where maybe they haven’t.
They don’t have the need of transitioning into a care facility type home, but they want that communal space, something that’s safe where they can meet people. they don’t need a giant apartment or things like that. Maybe they can’t afford it. so lots of different options that folks can look at to put people into their home and have these companies that manage these folks to provide them a great living space.
Dylan Silver (08:10)
Four of tenants in a single family, right? But then when you start looking at additional tenants, now you’re getting into a commercial property. Is that a tough hurdle to jump? Is there zoning and regulations that can be challenging for especially newer folks to navigate?
Micah Shelton (08:27)
Yeah, so you want to check with your local county or city requirements on occupancy. So it’s non-related adults in a home. And what does that look like? Every city, county, state is a little bit different. I’m fortunate here in the suburbs of Portland, Oregon, that the adults that can live in the home is 16. That’s unheard of. most are in the four to five person range.
Now, companies like PadSplit are utilizing some creative techniques to get around those occupancy rules. With Pad Split, you become a member of the PadSplit community. Now you’re all related because you’re all members of a specific company. And so then they have an agreement with PadSplit. PadSplit has an agreement with the homeowner. So that’s how they get around some of those loopholes to get eight to ten people in a home. Fortunately, we didn’t have to do that here in the Portland market.
For the Sober Living folks, they have their requirements, their rules on how many folks they can put into bed, because they’re actually going above and beyond what pad split would do. So in my first house, they’re putting two, sometimes three individuals in a room, as a shared space. So my first home, they have 14 men living in that home at any given time. So fortunately, I fall
within that sixteen person category. So there was no loopholes that we had to do, but that is definitely something you want to check with your local county or city managers on occupancy rules.
Dylan Silver (09:47)
There’s so much to unpack there, right? First, sixteen, wow, right. I think a lot of folks may be shocked and may want to look into the history. Hey, why is it four in my market and sixteen up there, by where Micah is? Are you seeing because of that rule in place where you can have sixteen unrelated adults in the same property, is there more momentum behind these types of deals, Sober Living, Co-Living, etc.?
Micah Shelton (10:52)
for sure in my county. this Sober Living company is an East Coast based company this is their first branch out of the New York and Pennsylvania area into the Portland market. And they’re targeting Clackamas County where I live because of those occupancy rules. Portland has done a really good job. I know Seattle’s done a really good job on tweaking those rules to make housing affordable. This falls into that.
increasing the amount of adults that can live in a home. 16 is unheard of. but to get back to your question, yes, these companies are looking for areas that meet those can meet the needs of the people and not have a lot of loopholes and jump through a bunch of hoops to, get occupancy rules changed and things like that. But I think communities as a whole, nationwide, are going to be changing their rules and there’s a lot of
folks from that own Pad Split and different organizations that are lobbying to change those occupancy rules so that we can make housing affordable for folks.
Dylan Silver (11:44)
There’s never gonna be a hard and fast rule when it comes to all things in one asset class in real estate. Certainly, Co-Living has its complexities, but if you’re looking at underwriting a deal in your neck of the woods and you’re trying to find, okay, well, how many people are we gonna put in here? How much work is gonna go into it? What maybe is this property gonna appreciate in a specific period of time? what do the rents look like? What’s potential vacancies look like?
What’s your underwriting process right now for Co-Living deals?
Micah Shelton (12:13)
Yeah, so I’m trying to buy homes off market. I utilize wholesalers a lot of times. I’m not one that’s out, targeting different folks that are in foreclosure and things like that. But I am trying to find a good deal on a home, get it for the right purchase price, knowing that for me, my average renovation on a home most of these homes are over two thousand square feet. Most of them are three to four bedroom, three bath, ideally, because if you think you’re putting twelve people in there or more.
That’s three to one bathroom, four to one bathroom. You really don’t want to get above that ratio. So I’m looking at those options and then knowing that’s going to take me at least $100,000 to renovate that home. And that’s updating the bathrooms, updating the bedrooms, framing those walls, doing the egress windows. So then the loan structure that I’m using at the end is a DSCR loan, which is a debt service cover ratio loan, which means what are market rents for?
that area for a five bedroom or a six bedroom home. and then whatever that number equates to. So in my market, generally for a home that size is about $4,500 a month. They take that number and they reverse engineer and that dictates how much I can borrow. So on the first project we did, that $4,500 at today’s interest rate, I think I was at seven and a quarter ish percent, ended up being that I could borrow $625,000.
So that’s my all-in number that I want to get back out of my refinance. So I need to purchase the house, renovate the house at $100,000 to $125,000, and be in it $625,000 or less. And that loan is covered by the rent. So with my first project, we’re getting $6,000 a month from the company, but it’s similar to a triple net lease where they’re paying the taxes, they’re paying the utilities.
They’re doing any damage that happens. you have more wear and tear on the home for sure. So in our lease, it’s specified that I get to walk the property every six months, and we can go over if there’s extra wear and tear and extra damage, that does fall on the company to assess and address. your big CapEx expenditures, that’s going to fall on me as the homeowner. So if it needs a roof, there’s some big plumbing issue, those are gonna fall on me to maintain and fix while I own the home.
Dylan Silver (14:18)
Triple net lease on a Sober Living, that really sounds like a really well-structured deal. they’re taking care of the taxes. And then you also mentioned the seven, I believe seven and a half percent or roughly around their rate for the DSCR. I think some folks who may have heard of DSCR but may be unfamiliar with exactly how it works, maybe a fair degree of trepidation. Hey, this is something new. Hey, I’ve heard of this, but I don’t know how this is gonna.
Work, on a larger deal, what happens if X, Y, and Z happens? Was there any of that on your first DSCR?
Micah Shelton (14:50)
No, it was pretty seamless. there was lots of companies that are doing DSCR loans right now. the beauty is, yes, they take my credit into consideration, but really the property is what’s dictating the loan and what the property’s capable of. so it took a lot of my personal W two income as a firefighter. That really wasn’t even a consideration what I make or what other properties I have, because it’s really that one
Property is the focus. What is it going to bring in? And can you get that number? now the cool thing was the company I’m working with has been great. I can get a lease in place prior. So I did hard money lending to purchase it, hard money to renovate it. I get a lease in place, and then I’m able to refinance and show, hey, I have this lease in place. Now
One concern that’s come up is many underwriters don’t like commercial leases on residential properties. So we structured initially with one of the owners of the company. We get that personal lease guarantee, we get the first month’s deposit, we get a month under our belt. Ultimately that lease is going to be in the company name down the road. But so that’s one little loophole that we had to jump through was the underwriters.
not really liking that you’re leasing to a company versus a person. Even though a company should be more stable if you vetted that company than a person would be. they’re a more long-term tenant. Their goal is to stay in that house forever. So I think some of those rules will change over time as we see more and more of these homes getting put into play. But that was one loophole that we had to navigate.
Dylan Silver (16:20)
Want to get to the other side of this? We’ve talked about what it looks like as an investor and what it looks like in Sober Living. If someone is a Sober Living operator and they’re hearing this and they’re saying, Well, I don’t want to have to go and purchase the property, but I would like to operate on the premise of someone who has a Co-Living space. What makes a compelling pitch? If I’m a Sober Living operator, what makes a compelling pitch to an investor like yourself?
Micah Shelton (16:45)
I think realistically, you’re coming in at a higher price point for rent, you’re maintaining the home, you’re taking on the responsibility of utilities, maintenance, at a premium, so to speak. And to anybody that owns a home, that’s gonna be appealing. Now, you do have to sell me on 14 people when I first thought of that.
As a Co-Living home, I was going to do eight. Now all of a sudden you’re saying 14. To me, that was like, man, this house is going to get trashed. one thing I did was I went and visited two of their homes that they had already in operation and saw what they looked like after six months or a year of operation. And the company that I vetted and choose to work with had very nice homes that were very well maintained. and I think that’s a big thing that folks need to do.
Because not every operator in these environments is the same. And as a fireman, we go in homes all the time, care homes, Sober Living homes, and we see a lot of times the worst of the worst. And that is definitely not the operator that you want who has a no-care attitude. you really want to vet somebody that really does have a passion for these people and wants a safe and healthy environment for them and is providing that stepping stool as they navigate getting back into
The real world, so to speak, after coming out of a treatment plan, and now they’re is Sober Living home for 90 days or so, that are really trying to give them a nice, comfortable environment to transition back into society, so to speak. and they’re out there. So I think there’s tons of them out there that’s their passion. Our passion as investors is owning real estate, owning the homes and having a nice property that’s appreciating.
And I think the two can go hand in hand. It’s just doing a little due diligence.
Dylan Silver (18:23)
this reminds me on a larger scale, in a different manner, of like a short-term rental arbitrage, right? And sometimes when people think about the SDR arbitrage, they’re thinking, well, tough to get the investor to say yes to that. And you mentioned, well, worried about it getting trashed. I’m a firefighter, mentioned I’ve seen the worst of the worst. When folks are thinking about, well, how do I make an offer to a
Co-Living operator that’s going to be compelling to them, mentioning, hey, we’ll take care of the taxes. Come check out our properties. not only that, but we have the experience running this so we know what to expect in X, Y, and Z. Then the investor’s gonna start thinking, well, this is hands off. And I’ve seen their properties. I’ve got confidence that mine will look something like theirs. Yeah.
Micah Shelton (19:09)
For sure, for sure.
Dylan Silver (19:10)
I want to pivot here and talk about out of your backyard, in a different market investing, right? So you’re in Oregon, you’re also investing in Indiana, I believe, but you mentioned you’ve got that boots on the ground. For folks who are looking at another market, let’s say they’re in Oregon, they’re looking at Indiana, or they’re in, California looking at Texas. As a Texas realtor, we see a lot of that. what is the
proper steps that people should take to establish those boots on the ground, to do their due diligence before they go and buy a property.
Micah Shelton (20:17)
Yeah. I got fortunate that I had a friend that moved to Indiana. So I had somebody that I trusted from the firehouse that was living out there doing the same thing. So that was a bonus that I had. I became the real estate investing guy who was investing out of state. And so I had a lot of my colleagues wanting to do the same. because Oregon and Portland particularly is an expensive market.
and so to buy rentals can be challenging. Going out to Indiana, the price points were a lot more affordable. You could get into a home for a hundred to one hundred and twenty-five thousand that would rent for twelve to fifteen hundred dollars a month. so you’re hitting that one percent rule. A lot of the guys I work with ended up going into other communities that I wasn’t investing in Indiana. So my response to them was go out and visit for one.
If you’re gonna buy a $125,000 house, spending $500 to $1,000 to go out there for a handful of days and really drive the neighborhoods, drive the community is important. So you get your eyes on it. Number two is reaching out to multiple property managers, seeing what their book of business looks like, and seeing if they’re, meeting them. Having Zoom meetings with them before you go out, going out, having them show you some of their properties, having them show you some homes in the community that are for sale.
And you’re going to get a vibe when you meet an individual on whether they’re a good property manager. So I was able to do that with my property manager. We were in Greenfield, Indiana, and Shelbyville, Indiana, walking his properties that he managed, touring other properties, and then ultimately buying homes and bringing them on with him. Most property managers have a book of
contacts for your maintenance, your electricians, your plumbers. So asking them about that, vetting some of those folks while you’re there. It’s just like you would do on your own home. You’re not going to just go with the first guy that shows up and rings the doorbell. You’re going to, get a few bids. You’re going to meet a few people. It does take a little bit of legwork, but ultimately you’re establishing that team that you feel confident in that’s going to maintain your property remotely.
Dylan Silver (22:16)
what’s your outlook as far as hold times when you’re looking at comparing, maybe a SFR duplex, triplex, quadplex to Co-Living? What’s the hold times that you’re looking at?
Micah Shelton (22:27)
For me personally, I’m looking at 10 to 20 years. I’m getting close to retirement from the fire department. I have about five years to go, and I’ll still be fairly young. And so versus going out and getting another job that helps me with health care and things like that for my family, this real estate market, this package that I put together ultimately is going to assist my retirement for 10 years until I get to Medicare.
it’s gonna assist me, beyond that even with some monthly cash flow. So for me, I’m looking at 10, 15, 20 years, depending on the property. And then ultimately either, leaving them in my trust to my kids or selling them one at a time and utilizing those funds to continue, funding our life. Or hopefully, I have some goals with investing in maybe an Airbnb or a vacation property for my family.
these properties over time will give me that flexibility, as I get older.
Dylan Silver (23:16)
When people are looking at let’s look at Indiana in particular, I’m imagining more of a cash flow play than an appreciation play. Is that a fair assessment?
Micah Shelton (23:26)
Yeah, Indiana was very unique. COVID did amazing things for appreciation back there when folks weren’t having to, live in Portland or live in California and they could go to Indianapolis, which does have a lot of cool stuff. wouldn’t be my personal choice, but they do have a football team and a basketball team and the Indy 500. There’s things going on in Indianapolis. those home prices did go up in value.
So we got fortunate that we were buying homes in the $60,000, $70,000 range that ultimately are now worth $150,000, which they didn’t see that appreciation at all for a long, long time. Now I think that has slowed down a little bit. So it is a little bit more of a cash flow game versus an appreciation game. But like a good friend of mine just bought a house for $125,000 out there, a little three-bedroom, one and a half bath home.
He’s getting $1,500 a month. So he’s making $300,000 a month on his property. He could pay that off quicker if he chose, using his W-2 income, using other, avenues. and then you would have this property that’s still cash flowing into his retirement. I’m speaking of these fire guys, but for anybody, they’re gonna cash flow a little bit more than they would here in Portland when you’re paying four to
Five to six hundred thousand dollars.
Dylan Silver (24:40)
Do you get guys coming to you, other firefighters, they’re at the station and they’re telling you, Hey, I see you’re doing real estate. I’m not sure where I fit into this. I’m interested, but I’m not sure. What does that conversation look like?
Micah Shelton (24:51)
Yeah. first and foremost, my biggest encouragement, most of these guys want to own a home here in the Portland metro area. So if they’re saving money for that, my number one thing I tell is the house hacking model. Try to buy a duplex, try to buy a triplex, live in one of them. It might not be your first choice, it might not be your spouse’s first choice, but that will snowball you into a better situation one to two years from now. So that’s always my first
Plan of attack is say, hey, have you looked at this with your first-time home buyer incentives at buying something that’s going to pay you monthly and reduce your biggest expense? So that’s number one. Number two is I put them in contact with my folks, that are in Indiana. and if they have twenty thousand, thirty thousand, fifty thousand to deploy, I get that ball rolling with them on what that looks like.
the cash on cash return for what they’re going to invest, what does it mean to tie up that money? when can you pull it back out? Can you pull it back out? Or is it going to be locked in and you’re going to cash flow the three to five hundred a month? Are you comfortable with that? Crunching some of those numbers with them. just so they can wrap their mind around the full scope of what’s involved and that it’s doable when you have, like you said, the right team in place, that you can have a cash flowing asset.
still in today’s market.
Dylan Silver (26:03)
Wanna ask you a question as we’re coming up on time here. being that you’re in everyday situations that folks would describe as emergencies and, where you’re seeing in many cases the worst of the worst, right? You’re also seeing the best of the best, but you’re seeing the worst of the worst. Does this
maybe change the perspective that you have or give you a unique perspective on investing in real estate as a whole.
Micah Shelton (26:25)
I think for me I love the renovation component of real estate, turning something that’s in rough shape into a beautiful home, a beautiful thing that a family or somebody is a Sober Living company is going to benefit from. that brings me enjoyment as well as the long-term benefits of owning the real estate. I think there is
a ton of opportunity for distressed properties. There are homeowners and people that have bought homes that just can’t afford them right now. And so for me, while it wrenches on my heart that somebody can’t afford to live in their home, there are, challenges out there that they need to overcome. Ultimately that home needs to be revitalized and put into play for a new family and a new opportunity for somebody to make that
their home and something healthy and happy for their family going forward. So for me, I look at it as there’s a lot of opportunity out there. There’s a lot of homes that are distressed that wouldn’t take much to get back on track and get back to being useful and a nice property for folks. so I just see a lot of opportunity out there and a lot of potential in every community.
Dylan Silver (27:30)
Follow-up question to that. I have seen a lot of investors who look at fire damage properties, and there’s a lot that goes into that, right? when folks are looking at fire damaged properties, any feedback or advice for someone who may be underwriting a deal like that?
Micah Shelton (27:42)
Definitely get structural engineers in there to look at the structure. fire, it can cause minimal damage. It can look bad on the surface and not be that bad. a board gets, you get a fire in an attic and the wood gets, singed and it might actually be structurally sound. You don’t know until you actually cut into it a little bit on how much damage was done. smoke is atrocious. It takes way longer to get smoke smell out of anything. So think of your sheetrock.
flooring, most of that either has to come out or multiple layers of like a Kills product to encapsulate it. so really getting a structural engineer and a contractor in there to say, what actually do I need to rebuild and how extensive is this going to be? Because it could be way more than you think. Think of all the wires that got melted. You’re probably gonna have to rewire the whole house. The plumbing, your PVC pipes, your PEX pipes, they’re probably all destroyed. So your numbers are going to be
exponentially skewed from your standard renovation on a building that’s had significant damage. So I would keep that in mind for sure.
Dylan Silver (28:39)
we’re coming up on time here. Micah, any new projects, activities that you’re working on these days? Also anything you’d like to mention directly to our audience?
Micah Shelton (28:47)
we’re renovating our second Sober Living home for the same company. And that’s gonna be a seven-bedroom house right in the same area here in suburbs of Portland. So that’s cool. We’re looking to do three more for the same company next year. So I’m always looking for lending options. if there’s folks out there that, private money lenders and things like that, I would love to have you reach out to me. one passion project I’m working on that I don’t know if we’re gonna
Get it to the finish line is I found a 15-unit motel. And if anybody’s familiar with Bandon, Oregon is a golfer’s paradise. That’s you’re either going there to fish or you’re going there to golf. It’s on the Oregon coast. It’s one of the most underdeveloped communities on the coast right now, but one of the top 10 golf courses in the nation. So you have wealthy folks flying in all the time.
And we’re working with a gentleman who’s 80 years old, who is selling his motel that we would love to buy and renovate into a beautiful retreat for golfers to come to with your golf simulators and putting greens and all that. So I’m a golfer. It’s a little bit of a passion project if we can get the terms right. But we’re working on that. So if anybody’s interested in golf and real estate, by all means send me a DM on Instagram and I’d love to chat with you about it.
Dylan Silver (29:56)
Micah Shelton, thank you so much for joining us today. Thanks for your time.
Micah Shelton (30:00)
I appreciate
it.
Go deeper on this topic
Sober Living Home Investing: Rents, DSCR, and Occupancy
{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"PodcastEpisode","name":"How One Sober Living Rental Generates $6,000/Month | Micah Shelton's Real Estate Strategy","url":"https://wp.investorfuel.com/real-estate-pros-show/how-one-sober-living-rental-generates-6000-month-micah-sheltons-real-estate-strategy/","datePublished":"2026-11-21T00:00:41Z","partOfSeries":{"@type":"PodcastSeries","name":"Real Estate Pros Show","url":"https://investorfuel.com/real-estate-pros-show/"},"description":"Oregon-based investor and firefighter Micah Shelton explains how a co-living renovation became a hands-off Sober Living Rental, with an operator leasing the property and managing residents. He shares practical details on occupancy rules, renovations, DSCR financing, underwriting and due diligence, then discusses out-of-state investing and assessing fire-damaged homes.","associatedMedia":{"@type":"VideoObject","name":"How One Sober Living Rental Generates $6,000/Month | Micah Shelton's Real Estate Strategy","embedUrl":"https://www.youtube.com/embed/KDFVQWEBSfg","thumbnailUrl":"https://i.ytimg.com/vi/KDFVQWEBSfg/hqdefault.jpg","uploadDate":"2026-11-21T00:00:41Z","description":"Oregon-based investor and firefighter Micah Shelton explains how a co-living renovation became a hands-off Sober Living Rental, with an operator leasing the property and managing residents. He shares practical details on occupancy rules, renovations, DSCR financing, underwriting and due diligence, then discusses out-of-state investing and assessing fire-damaged homes."},"subjectOf":{"@type":"Article","url":"https://wp.investorfuel.com/blog/sober-living-home-investing-2/"}}