Urban Short-Term Rentals: Event Demand and the Midterm Hedge
An urban short-term rental strategy does not work like a beach or ski playbook. In an event-driven metro, demand is roughly flat across the calendar and tied to specific dates — a home game, a graduation, a convention — which removes the shoulder season you would normally use to catch up on maintenance, repricing and capital work.
Andy Tompkins owns the iTrip franchise covering Franklin County and Hocking Hills in Ohio. Before that he ran data operations and analytics for a single-family REIT that operated roughly 25,000 rental units, including budgeting and pricing. He builds budgets and pro formas the same way for 12 units that he did for 25,000.
What follows: how to define the submarket you are actually competing in, why cutting nightly rate is the wrong first lever, what belongs in a pro forma you hand an owner, where midterm rentals beat short-term in restrictive suburbs, and the safety exposure almost nobody audits.
Key takeaways
- Underwrite the submarket, not the metro. Tompkins treats Columbus as eight or nine submarkets with different demand drivers, so citywide averages are useless for projecting a specific address.
- Event-driven metros lose the off-season in both directions — December through January ran as hot as the preceding months, which means steadier cash flow but no recovery window.
- When occupancy drops, rate is the last lever. If a comparable property across the street is $100 a night cheaper, a great-looking listing still loses; the fix is usually furnishings and guest experience.
- In suburbs where HOAs and condo boards ban sub-30-day stays, one-to-four-month midterm rentals are the compliant play, and hybrid programs can keep peak event nights on the short-term calendar.
- Safety is the most neglected area in STR operations and no outside party enforces it — the owner carries the exposure for things like fireplace ash disposal and recalled baby gear.
From the Real Estate Pros Show
This article draws on an interview with Andy Tompkins of iTrip Columbus (Ohio STR Partners, LLC) on the Real Estate Pros Show, hosted by Scott Bursey.
Why a Metro Is Not One Short-Term Rental Market
Stop underwriting a city. Tompkins does not view Columbus as a market at all — he sees eight or nine submarkets that behave differently and have different drivers of demand. A downtown condo near the arena, a near-campus house, and a Hocking Hills cabin share a metro and almost nothing else.
That makes the most common underwriting shortcut the most dangerous one. “It’s not as easy as saying, well, the average property in this market does X, so that’s what my property should do,” Tompkins says. A citywide ADR or occupancy figure is an average of properties that do not compete with each other.
The alternative is building a custom competitor set for the specific address. That means identifying the properties a guest would actually be choosing between — same submarket, same sleep capacity, same demand driver — and benchmarking against those. For an operator with multiple units, blending that external set with observed performance from your own portfolio gives you a second, cleaner data source that no market tool has.
Practically, this is a four-item checklist before you project revenue on any urban STR:
- Which submarket is this, and what specific demand pulls people into it?
- Who are the 8–15 properties a guest would compare this one against?
- What is the sleep capacity relative to that peer set, not relative to the city?
- Where does this property sit on quality and price within that set today — not after you renovate it?
Everything downstream, including pricing and the pro forma, is built on that definition. Get the comp set wrong and the rest of the model is confidently wrong.
Event-Driven Demand and the Disappearing Shoulder Season
In an event metro, the off-season flattens out. Tompkins notes that over the last two years, December, January and February ran just as hot as the months preceding them. Demand was consistent across the calendar.
That is structurally different from how vacation rental systems are designed. Beach and ski programs are built around surging through peak season and recovering in the off-season — catching up on deferred maintenance, deep cleans, refurnishing, and owner stays. “I don’t have recovery seasons anymore,” Tompkins says.
The reason is what brings guests in the first place. Very rarely does someone go to Columbus for the sake of going to Columbus. They come for a Blue Jackets game, an Ohio State football game, or graduation. Demand is attached to dates on a calendar, not to weather.
Two consequences for how you run the asset:
- Cash flow is more consistent, which changes what you can underwrite. A pure vacation market has to plan for inbound cash dropping sharply for months at a time. A flat event-driven calendar supports steadier debt service and more predictable owner distributions.
- You have to schedule downtime deliberately. Without a natural lull, carpet replacement, repainting and mattress cycles have to be blocked out as intentional vacancies, not slotted into a dead season that no longer exists.
Local event knowledge also drives pricing in a way national tools miss. A pricing algorithm does not know the Arnold Sports Classic is coming to Columbus in March — and it certainly does not know that the cleaning fee for those dates needs to go up roughly $75 because of bronzer and tanning oil stains on furniture. That is an operator input, not a software output.
Lowering the prices should be kind of like the last step that you’re looking to do. The competitive position for a property matters as much as the pricing. I’ve evaluated properties that look fantastic, but it really doesn’t matter if their peer across the street is a hundred dollars less a night.
— Andy Tompkins, iTrip Columbus
Pricing: Why Cutting the Nightly Rate Is the Last Move
When occupancy falls, the reflex is to drop the nightly rate. Tompkins argues that should be close to the final step, not the first. “Lowering the prices should be kind of like the last step that you’re looking to do. The competitive position for a property matters as much as the pricing.”
The diagnostic question is where your property sits inside its peer set, not what number is on your calendar. Tompkins has evaluated properties that look fantastic and still underperform, because the peer across the street is $100 a night cheaper for a comparable stay. No rate adjustment fixes a positioning problem; it just transfers margin to the guest.
His sequence when a unit is underbooking:
- Pull market demand data for that specific property and submarket, not the metro.
- Blend it with observed performance from comparable units already under management.
- Identify the gap between where the property should be performing and where it is.
- Decide whether the gap is positional (furnishings, photos, guest experience, amenities) or genuinely a rate problem.
Step four usually leads to a hard conversation. If an owner wants a specific revenue number, the competitors in that submarket have already dictated a level of furnishings and guest experience required to compete there. Hitting the number means spending money, not discounting. Owners who are not prepared to invest should reset the revenue target instead.
One more framing worth borrowing: a vacant Tuesday is not automatically a failure. Tompkins starts every pricing conversation by establishing owner priorities, because some owners use the property themselves part of the year and want high returns without high occupancy. Optimizing for occupancy when the owner wants yield-per-stay is the wrong objective function.
What Belongs in a Short-Term Rental Pro Forma
A usable short-term rental pro forma is two pages, and it starts with a phone call, not a spreadsheet.
Tompkins runs a 10 to 15 minute call before building anything, to establish the owner’s priorities for the property, intended use, bedroom count and sleep capacity. Those inputs change the model materially — sleep capacity in particular drives which comp set the property belongs in.
Page one — the numbers:
- Monthly rental revenue projections
- Monthly occupancy projections
- OTA fees broken out as a separate line, because they come out of the owner’s share rather than the manager’s
- Management fee
- Net operating income before any debt service or building obligations
- Sensitivity analysis showing what happens to the bottom line as average daily rate or occupancy moves up or down
Breaking out OTA fees separately is the detail most owner-facing projections skip. Airbnb, Vrbo and Booking fees are real dollars off the top, and burying them inside a gross revenue figure produces a cash flow number the owner will never actually see in their account.
Page two — who is operating it: a detailed overview of services provided and the operator’s background. Owners are underwriting the manager as much as the asset.
The delivery matters as much as the document. Tompkins’ early mistake was treating pro formas as a volume product — generating them quickly and emailing a PDF. “It’s important information, and it should be exchanged in a venue and a forum that matches the level of importance of the information.” He now walks every owner through the projection live, on a 30-minute video or in-person meeting, and surfaces objections while the numbers are in front of them. He calls it slowing down to speed up.
Midterm Rentals as the Regulatory and Suburban Workaround
In most of the Columbus area, the municipality is not the obstacle. Columbus requires registration, and very few surrounding municipalities impose meaningful restrictions on use. The restrictive layer is private: homeowners associations and condo boards, which are frequently far stricter than the city and often ban stays under 30 days outright.
That is exactly where a midterm rental strategy wins. A one-to-four-month stay clears a 30-day minimum and opens up suburban inventory that is otherwise unusable for nightly rentals. Tompkins sees a meaningful number of units migrating into that framework.
Demand for midterm stays comes from employment, not tourism — traveling medical professionals and traveling professionals generally. Large institutional employers concentrate it. Tompkins points to the strong Air Force presence in Dayton as a market with a large population of midterm rental candidates, which is part of why it is on his expansion list.
Operationally, longer stays change the service model in ways that catch short-term operators out:
- Mid-stay linen refreshes rather than a single turnover clean
- Restocking consumables during the stay
- Maintaining a consistent standard of care across what might be a one- or two-month occupancy rather than a weekend
The strongest version is hybrid. For an owner who wants revenue certainty but does not want to give up the nights that command the highest nightly rates, you build a program that blocks peak event dates for short-term bookings and fills the surrounding weeks with midterm stays. That requires a manager with the authority to custom-fit the program — something Tompkins can do as the local franchise owner rather than running a one-size template.
The Safety Exposure Most Owners Never Audit
Safety is the single most neglected area in short-term and midterm rentals, and there is no outside party enforcing it. “There is really no one advocating on our behalf, and as a result the onus is on us as operators,” Tompkins says. The financial and reputational downside is severe and the upside of ignoring it is cosmetic.
Two concrete examples he gives:
- Fireplace ash disposal. You may not love a warning sign with a QR code next to the fireplace. Weigh that against what happens when a guest dumps hot ashes into a plastic bin on a wood deck.
- Recalled amenities. Providing a pack and play feels like good hospitality. When did you last check whether that specific model has been recalled? An amenity added in good faith can introduce a liability that did not exist before.
The hardest exposure to catch belongs to owners who converted a home they lived in. Tompkins’ point is that long familiarity creates blindness — you stop seeing the loose stair rail, the unlabeled breaker, the step down into the garage, because you have navigated them for years without thinking. A fresh set of eyes finds in twenty minutes what the owner has walked past for a decade.
The operational discipline that backstops all of it is simple and expensive: someone walks every property after the clean, before the next guest arrives. Tompkins or a team member does this on every unit. His reasoning is about failure modes, not perfection — a guest being notified of a problem before they walk in the door is one thing, and a guest discovering a missed bathroom themselves is an entirely different kind of failure.
Frequently asked questions
How should I price a short-term rental when occupancy drops?
Treat rate reduction as the last step, not the first. Start by checking where the property sits inside its real competitor set — same submarket, same sleep capacity, same demand driver. If a comparable property nearby is priced $100 a night below you, the gap is positional and discounting only transfers margin to the guest.
If the comp set shows your furnishings, photos or amenities are behind the competition, the fix is capital, not price. Either invest to compete at that level or reset the revenue expectation.
Are midterm rentals better than short-term rentals in suburban markets?
Often yes, because the constraint in suburbs is usually the HOA or condo board rather than the municipality, and those bodies frequently ban stays under 30 days. A one-to-four-month midterm stay clears that threshold and makes otherwise unusable inventory productive.
Midterm also suits markets with large institutional employers — traveling medical professionals, traveling professionals, and military-adjacent demand. Expect to add mid-stay linen refreshes and consumable restocking to the service model.
What should a short-term rental pro forma actually show an owner?
Monthly revenue and occupancy projections, OTA fees broken out as their own line, the management fee, and net operating income before debt service — plus a sensitivity showing how the bottom line moves with changes in average daily rate and occupancy.
OTA fees deserve their own line because they come out of the owner’s share. Rolling them into gross revenue produces a cash flow number the owner will never actually receive.
Do urban short-term rentals have an off-season?
In event-driven metros, often not in any meaningful way. In Columbus, December through February have recently run as hot as the months before them, because demand is tied to specific dates — games, graduations, conventions — rather than weather.
The upside is steadier cash flow than a beach or ski market, where inbound revenue can drop sharply for half the year. The tradeoff is that there is no natural lull for deferred maintenance or refurnishing, so you have to block that downtime deliberately.
What safety items should a short-term rental owner check first?
Start with anything that can burn, fall or has been subject to a recall. Fireplaces need clear ash disposal instructions posted at the fireplace. Guest-provided baby gear such as pack and plays should be checked against current recall notices before it stays in the unit.
Then have someone who has never lived in the property walk it. Owners who converted their own home are the most likely to miss hazards, because long familiarity makes them invisible.
The bottom line
Before you touch the nightly rate on an underperforming urban rental, rebuild the comp set for that specific address and decide whether the problem is price or position — most of the time it is position, and that conclusion changes what you spend money on next.