Pulling Comps for ARV: Distance, Size, and Barrier Rules
Pulling comps for ARV is an elimination exercise, not a collection exercise. The rules that survive contact with a skeptical cash buyer are narrow: stay inside a half mile, stay within roughly 200 to 300 square feet of the subject, match the bed/bath configuration, never cross a highway, and throw out anything without a recorded sale price.
Nathan Hogue underwrites wholesale deals at volume for a nationwide operation based in San Antonio and runs a comping and underwriting tool called Compr. In a live walkthrough of a 3-bed, 3-bath, 2,400-square-foot subject, his system surfaced 250 possible comparables and gated them down to five. Three of those five got cut on camera.
Below: the exact gates he applies, how the surviving set becomes an ARV and a rehab number, how that converts to a max allowable offer with an assignment fee built in, and what the seller and the buyer each get to see.
Key takeaways
- Cap comp distance at a half mile and never cross a highway — physical barriers separate submarkets even when the mileage looks fine.
- Hold comps within roughly 200–300 square feet of the subject either way, and match configuration (a 3/3 subject comps against 3/2.5 and 3/3, not a 4/2).
- Drop any comparable with no recorded sales price. Without the number it is not a match, it is a listing.
- Average the surviving set, then shave each one for wiggle room — and refuse to anchor to the high outlier even when three sit far above the pack.
- At a couple hundred leads a month, underwriting speed is an efficiency question. At a thousand a month at five minutes each, it eats the entire day and becomes the constraint on how many deals you can pencil.
From the Real Estate Pros Show
This article draws on an interview with Nathan Hogue of Compr on the Real Estate Pros Show, hosted by Quentin Edmonds.
Why Comp Selection, Not Comp Count, Decides Your ARV
The data is never the problem. On a single San Antonio-area property, Hogue’s system pulled 250 potential comparable sales, then gated them down to five that actually made sense. The work is subtraction.
That matters because an ARV is not a number you hold privately. You have to hand it to a cash buyer who will re-comp it, to a hedge fund with its own buy box, or to a seller who has already heard — in Hogue’s words — eighteen different offers. If your number is built from a scatter of sales across three subdivisions and two highway corridors, the first person who checks will find that out in under a minute, and the offer loses credibility along with the comp.
A defendable comp set is one where you can state the reason each comp is in and each rejected sale is out. Too far. No recorded price. Wrong configuration. That’s the standard: not “here are three similar houses nearby” but “here are five sales I can justify line by line, and here is why I dropped the rest.”
The practical consequence is that your comping process needs explicit disqualification rules written down before you open a map. Otherwise you select the comps that support the number you already wanted, which is how wholesalers end up with contracts nobody will take assignment on. The gates below are the ones Hogue runs on every file.
The Gates: Half-Mile, Square Footage, Bed/Bath, and Barriers
Run the subject through these in order, starting tight and expanding only as far as you must to get a workable set.
- Start in the subdivision, then expand. Begin with the subject’s own subdivision. Widen the radius outward only until you have enough comps to underwrite — not until you have a number you like.
- Don’t cross the highway. On Hogue’s map the highways show as heavy orange lines, and comps on the far side are out regardless of distance. A major road splits a submarket in practice even when the drive is short.
- Half a mile is the cap. “I don’t like to do anything over a half mile, but you can if the comps are not as good,” Hogue said while dropping two otherwise reasonable sales for sitting just outside it. Rural markets force exceptions; suburban infill rarely does.
- Hold a 200–300 square foot window. Against a 2,400-square-foot subject, his surviving set ran roughly 2,300 to 2,700. That’s the band, both directions.
- Match configuration. The subject was a 3/3. The comps that stayed were 3/2.5 and 3/3. Half a bath of drift is tolerable; a bedroom of drift is not.
- Kill anything without a recorded sales price. One comp got dropped for exactly this reason: no price on record means it is not a real match, however good it looks otherwise.
Three of five comps came out of the demo set on those grounds. What remained was tighter, smaller, and far easier to defend — which is the point. A tight four-comp set beats a loose eight-comp set every time you have to explain yourself.
I don’t like to do anything over a half mile, but you can if the comps are not as good.
— Nathan Hogue, Compr
Turning the Comp Set Into a Number You Can Defend
Average the survivors, then come down. Hogue’s rule is to take a little off each comp before settling, which built in room to be wrong in the direction that doesn’t cost money. On the demo property that landed the ARV at roughly $255,000 to $256,000.
The more instructive part was what he refused to do. There were sales at $650,000, $655,000 and $700,000 sitting inside the search range. “Obviously you can’t anchor to the high one,” he said — and he could have pushed the ARV materially higher by giving those outliers weight. He didn’t. High comps in range are usually telling you something about a different product type, a renovation level you are not planning, or a pocket of the subdivision your subject isn’t in.
Conservative underwriting is not timidity. It is the difference between a contract that assigns and a contract you renegotiate twice before it dies. If the deal only works because you leaned on the top of the range, it does not work.
Then produce the paper. A CMA you can hand to a buyer, a lender, or a seller — showing which comps you used and which you eliminated — is what converts your opinion into something a third party will underwrite against. Keep the dropped comps and the reason codes attached to the file. When a buyer pushes back on your ARV, the fastest way to end the conversation is to show that you already considered and rejected the comp they are pointing at.
Scoping Rehab From Photos — and Where It Still Needs a Human
Rehab gets estimated twice in Hogue’s process. The first pass is a price-per-square-foot number for a rough bracket. The second pass is an itemized, line-by-line estimate priced off Home Depot cost data pulled into the system. On the demo property, the second pass came out around $60,000.
What makes the itemized version usable is traceability. The scope flags the specific photos driving each line — items 24, 27 and 29 were called out as “loose, heavily rippled, stained carpeting,” and you can click straight through to the image that produced the call. That is the same defensibility principle as the comp set: every number points back to its evidence.
Hogue’s own caveat is the part to take seriously. “Obviously there’s going to be some things it doesn’t catch,” he said. “Do your due diligence, go through it, make sure your numbers are correct.” Photo-based scoping sees finishes. It does not see a failed sewer lateral, foundation movement, knob-and-tube behind drywall, or a roof that photographs fine from the ground.
Treat an automated scope as a fast, consistent first draft that gets your offer out the door the same day, then verify before you are hard on earnest money. For a wholesaler the practical sequence is: scope from photos, offer, then walk it or send a contractor during inspection and adjust if the number moves. The speed advantage is in going first, not in skipping the verification.
From ARV to Max Allowable Offer and What Each Party Sees
The MAO math is two inputs. Set your assignment fee — $15,000 in the demo — and set your percentage of ARV, entered as 70. The calculation then backs into the highest price you can offer and still clear your fee at that percentage.
That produces a negotiating range rather than a single number. On the demo deal, Hogue’s guidance was to pitch the seller somewhere between roughly $370,000 and $395,000, with $395,000 as the ceiling. “Obviously you want to get them a little bit lower if you can, but you can go as high as 395.” Knowing your ceiling before the call is what keeps you from negotiating against yourself.
The output then splits into two packages, and the distinction is worth copying regardless of what software you run:
- Seller package: your offer, the rehab scope, the ARV, and the property photos. Your fee is not in it. The seller needs to understand how you arrived at the number, not what you earn on it.
- Buyer package: the same underwriting with your fee added on top — $15,000 stacked onto the $395,000 — so the buyer sees one price to close at.
The same comp set also feeds different exits. A listing agent gets a list price. A BRRRR buyer gets a different offer number with rehab, closing costs and hard money points broken out. Novation and retail-agent paths change which figures matter. One ARV, several ways to monetize it — and the discipline that makes the ARV defendable is what makes all of them hold.
When Underwriting Speed Actually Becomes the Bottleneck
Volume is what turns comping from a task into a constraint. Hogue’s company went from a couple hundred submissions a month to over a thousand — inside a week. At an average of about five minutes per underwrite, that math consumed his entire day. Acquisitions kept feeding leads; the underwriting desk became the governor on the whole business.
His reported numbers after rebuilding the process: 60 to 90 seconds per file, and closer to 30 seconds when the CRM is wired in via API so submissions are pre-underwritten before a human opens them. In that setup the underwriter’s job changes from building the file to auditing it — check the comps, check the scope, confirm the deal is real.
His framing is straightforward: “If I can underwrite two times the amount of deals, that means two times the amount of deals penciled, which means two times the amount of money in my pocket.”
The honest read for a smaller shop is different. If you are taking in a couple hundred leads a month, five minutes an underwrite is roughly 17 hours — a real cost, but not one that breaks the business. At that stage speed is an efficiency gain, not a survival issue, and the bigger returns usually come from tightening the comp gates so fewer bad deals get offers at all. The bottleneck is worth automating when lead flow starts outrunning the hours you have to evaluate it.
Frequently asked questions
How far away can a comp be before it stops being usable?
Half a mile is the working cap. Start inside the subject’s subdivision and expand outward only until you have enough usable sales, and treat anything past the half-mile mark as a last resort you have to justify. Rural and thinly traded markets force exceptions; dense suburban areas rarely do.
Distance alone isn’t the whole test. A sale a quarter mile away but across a highway is worse than one four tenths of a mile away in the same subdivision.
What square footage range should comps fall inside?
Roughly 200 to 300 square feet in either direction from the subject. On a 2,400-square-foot subject, that put Nathan Hogue’s surviving comps between about 2,300 and 2,700 square feet.
Wider than that and you are no longer comparing the same product, which forces you into adjustments a skeptical buyer can dispute. Tight beats numerous.
Why does crossing a highway disqualify a comparable sale?
A highway separates submarkets even when the distance looks acceptable on a map. Different school attendance zones, different buyer pools, different price per square foot. Hogue’s map shows highways as heavy orange lines specifically so underwriters avoid pulling across them.
Apply the same logic to any hard barrier — a river, a rail line, a commercial corridor, a city or county boundary that changes taxes or services.
How do you get from ARV to a maximum allowable offer with an assignment fee built in?
Set your target assignment fee and your percentage of ARV, then solve backward for the highest purchase price that still leaves that fee intact. In the demo, a $15,000 fee at 70% produced a seller-facing range of roughly $370,000 to $395,000, with $395,000 as the absolute ceiling.
Know the ceiling before you get on the phone. The range is your negotiating room, not a starting point.
Should the seller see your rehab scope and ARV in the offer package?
Yes — the scope, the ARV and the photos, but not your fee. Showing a seller how you arrived at the number separates you from the other offers they have fielded, and it gives them something concrete to evaluate instead of a bare price.
The buyer-facing version of the same package carries your fee added on top of the offer, so they see one number to close at.
The bottom line
Write your disqualification rules down and apply them before you look at a single price — half-mile cap, no highway crossings, 200 to 300 square feet, matched bed and bath, no unrecorded sales. The comps you throw out are what makes the ones you keep worth defending.