Hiring Acquisitions Reps: Recruiter Fees and Sourcing Rules
Hiring acquisitions reps through a recruiter typically costs $6,000 to $7,000 for a commission-only seat, or 15% to 20% of base salary for a salaried role — about $12,000 on an $80,000 base. That fee is contingent in most arrangements, meaning you pay nothing unless you hire the person.
Luke Smitherman of Crush Recruiters has recruited exclusively in the real estate investing space since 2019, placing acquisitions reps, sales leaders and support staff at wholesalers, flippers and lenders. Below: what the fee structures actually look like, where good acquisitions candidates come from, why outbound sourcing beats a job post, and the one call most founders should hand off.
Key takeaways
- Expect $6,000–$7,000 for a commission-only acquisitions placement, or 15–20% of base salary for salaried roles — roughly $12,000 on an $80,000 base.
- Contingency means no fee unless you hire; retainers front-load payment and remove the recruiter’s pressure to move fast.
- The best acquisitions candidates come out of roofing, home restoration and solar — in-home sales skills, already watching real estate investing content, no idea who’s hiring.
- Put a sales-oriented person on the first candidate call, not an admin and not the founder. The founder enters once the candidate is already sold on the company.
- Keep a bench even when you’re not hiring. From a cold start, a good acquisitions hire is two to four months away.
From the Real Estate Pros Show
This article draws on an interview with Luke Smitherman of Crush Recruiters on the Real Estate Pros Show, hosted by Quentin Edmonds.
What It Costs to Have Someone Else Fill the Seat
Two pricing structures dominate, and the split is based on how the role is paid.
- Commission-only acquisitions or sales rep: roughly $6,000 to $7,000 per placement.
- Salaried role: 15% to 20% of the base salary. On an $80,000 base, Smitherman says he’d typically charge 15%, so about $12,000.
Both are contingency arrangements. Nothing is owed unless the client actually hires someone the recruiter produced. Smitherman has tried the monthly retainer model that many general staffing firms run on and says it simply doesn’t work for his business — and he prefers it that way. Contingency forces speed. If you don’t hire, he doesn’t eat.
The objection he hears most is a math comparison, and it’s worth understanding because you’ve probably made it yourself: I could post that job on LinkedIn for a hundred bucks a day. Or: talent acquisition specialists are listed at $50,000 to $60,000 a year, so why is one hire worth six grand?
That pricing anchor is real, and it’s why his close rate sits around 20% of the operators he talks to. His read is that the resistance isn’t about whether the company needs help filling the seat. It’s that owners don’t see a meaningful difference between what a recruiter does and what they already do themselves with a job post.
The honest way to evaluate it: compare the fee not to the cost of a job post, but to the cost of a seat sitting empty for another quarter, plus the hours your sales leader spends screening unqualified applicants.
Why Posting the Job Is Not Recruiting
Most recruiting agencies are inbound. They post a job, wait for applications, interview whoever shows up, and forward the better ones. You are paying someone to do the screening step of a process you could run yourself.
Outbound sourcing is a different function entirely. Smitherman’s position is blunt: recruiting is a sales job. His team works LinkedIn outreach, an owned candidate database built over seven years, text messages and phone calls. Every motion is outbound, aimed at people who are not currently applying to anything.
The stack is lean and worth copying if you’re building this in-house:
- LinkedIn Sales Navigator for identifying and filtering candidates
- Apollo for pulling cell phone numbers
- A self-built applicant tracking system — created with an AI app builder, configured to auto-pull resumes from his inbox so nothing dies in email
- Calendly for candidate booking
Note what this is not: a replacement for your job posts. Most of his clients continue to run their own Indeed and LinkedIn listings and use outbound as a supplementary channel. Inbound catches people actively looking. Outbound catches people who are good at their job and not looking, which is a different and usually better pool.
The single biggest friction in outbound is one you already know from cold calling sellers. Nobody answers unknown numbers anymore. Standard practice is voicemail plus a follow-up text on every attempt, and accepting that the people who are genuinely interested will come back to you. It slows placement down. It doesn’t stop it.
Recruiting is a sales job. If you pay for a seller lead, you’re not going to send your HR department out there to close the deal. You’re not going to send your marketing department. You’re going to send a salesperson.
— Luke Smitherman, Crush Recruiters
Where Acquisitions Candidates Actually Come From
The strongest pipeline for acquisitions talent is adjacent in-home sales industries: roofing, home restoration and solar.
The profile is consistent. These are people who have sat at kitchen tables, handled objections from homeowners under stress, and closed in a single visit — the exact skill set an acquisitions rep uses. They are burned out on their current industry. And critically, they are already consuming real estate investing content on YouTube, Facebook and LinkedIn. They want in.
What they don’t have is a list of who’s hiring. Smitherman gets messages in his LinkedIn inbox every day from people asking whether there are any openings in their area — people who, as he points out, could simply Google investment companies in their city and contact them directly, and don’t.
That gap is the opportunity, and most operators ignore it. When he tells clients how many candidates want to work for them, roughly half shrug and say they’ll keep relying on whoever comes through Indeed.
If you want to work this channel yourself, the targeting is straightforward. Search LinkedIn for sales reps at roofing, restoration and solar companies in your market with two or more years of tenure. Pull cell numbers. Call, leave a voicemail, send a text. Lead with the fact that you buy houses and are hiring, because that alone is information they don’t currently have.
Keep the Founder Out of the First Call
Put a sales-oriented person on the first candidate conversation. Not an administrative assistant, and not the owner.
The logic follows from treating recruiting as a sales function. If you pay for a seller lead, you don’t send HR out to close it and you don’t send marketing. You send a closer. The candidate is a lead. They are evaluating you at least as hard as you are evaluating them, and the first call is where that evaluation happens.
The argument for keeping the founder out is subtler and more useful. Nobody on the planet will ever care about the business the way the owner does — and the owner shouldn’t expect them to. A commission-only 1099 acquisitions rep has no equity, no salary, no benefits, and sometimes no leads provided. Expecting that person to show up with ownership-level commitment on a first call distorts the founder’s read of them. Smitherman’s view is that founders can’t look at candidates through the right lens that early in the process.
The sequence he recommends:
- A recruiter or internal sales leader takes the first call. They sell the company, the culture and the process.
- That conversation moves the candidate from roughly 10% bought-in to 50% or better.
- The founder enters, talking to someone who already wants the job.
The founder conversation is still essential. It just works far better as the second or third touch than the first.
Reading What a Candidate Actually Wants
Most recruiter calls are transactional — six scripted questions, answered in order, nothing learned. Smitherman’s own path into recruiting started with taking exactly those calls while he sold industrial laundry services at Aramark, and noticing how impersonal they felt. He never moved jobs because of one.
A Houston placement shows the alternative. The candidate was in his mid-twenties and had only ever worked salaried roles. He had never considered a commission-only position and, on paper, was not a fit for one.
During the conversation Smitherman picked up on something the candidate never actually said: he wanted to run his own business one day. So he asked directly. The candidate opened up immediately.
That reframed the entire pitch. The job stopped being “commission-only acquisitions rep” and became an apprenticeship under someone who had been wholesaling for fifteen years — a chance to watch the good, the bad and the ugly up close. What the owner spends on marketing. Which marketing works and which doesn’t. Who his most important hires are. What he does during slow months. How he budgets. How the business affects his family.
The candidate took the role and succeeded in it.
The practical lesson for anyone interviewing acquisitions candidates: the stated motivation is rarely the real one. Money is almost never the full answer. Find the unstated ambition, then position the seat as the fastest route to it. A six-question script will never surface that.
Hiring Through an Uncertain Market
A large share of wholesalers are in a holding pattern on hiring right now. Smitherman’s description: they don’t know whether to add people or stick with what they have, so they’re waiting to see what happens. A smaller group is still hiring and growing.
His counterargument to waiting is about lead time. Conditions can turn fast, and if you have no bench when they do, you are two to four months out from a good hire. That is a full quarter of deal flow you don’t capture. Keeping a warm pipeline of candidates costs very little; starting from zero costs a season.
The underlying market pressure is visible in his own backyard. In Mobile, Alabama, homeowners insurance has climbed by roughly two to three thousand dollars a year over the last three years. That cost eats rental margin directly. One local wholesaler with about fifteen rental properties told him he can’t profitably rent out half of them anymore.
The practical effect is a shift in strategy. Investors in affected markets are moving away from adding to rental portfolios and toward fix and flip — which changes what kind of people they need to hire and who finances the deals.
Smitherman expects the growth to show up on the lending side, specifically among the smaller hard money lenders springing up to fund that flip volume. It’s a segment he describes as underserved by recruiters, which is usually a signal that it’s underserved by vendors generally.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a recruiter charge to fill an acquisitions or sales role at a real estate investing company?
For a commission-only acquisitions or sales rep, expect roughly $6,000 to $7,000 per placement. For salaried roles, the standard range is 15% to 20% of the base salary — about $12,000 on an $80,000 base, at the 15% end.
Fees vary by firm and by how hard the role is to fill. Specialist recruiters who work exclusively in real estate investing price differently than general staffing agencies, and the number is negotiable in both directions depending on volume.
What’s the difference between a contingency and a retainer recruiting agreement?
Contingency means you pay nothing unless you hire someone the recruiter sourced. A retainer means you pay a fee up front or monthly regardless of outcome.
Contingency shifts the risk to the recruiter and creates urgency — Smitherman prefers it specifically because it forces his team to work fast for clients. Retainers are more common in executive search, where the role is narrow and the search may take months. For a commission-only acquisitions seat, contingency is the structure most investor shops will encounter.
Which industries produce the best acquisitions candidates for real estate investors?
Roofing, home restoration and solar. All three train people in in-home sales — sitting with homeowners, handling objections, closing in a single visit — which transfers almost directly to acquisitions.
These candidates are frequently burned out on their industry and already watching real estate investing content online. The missing piece is that they don’t know which investment companies are hiring in their market, which means they rarely apply through normal channels.
Should the founder take the first interview call with a sales candidate?
No. Have a recruiter or an internal sales leader take the first call, then bring the founder in once the candidate is already sold on the company.
Two reasons. First, the candidate is evaluating you as much as you’re evaluating them, so the first touch needs to be someone who can sell. Second, a founder naturally expects ownership-level commitment, which is unrealistic to ask of a 1099 commission-only hire with no salary, benefits or equity — and that expectation distorts the founder’s judgment at the stage when it matters least.
Is it worth hiring outside help when you can just post the job on Indeed or LinkedIn?
It depends on whether you need more applicants or better ones. Job posts reach people actively looking for work. Outbound sourcing reaches people who are performing well somewhere else and aren’t applying to anything — generally a stronger pool for acquisitions.
Most of Smitherman’s clients do both: they run their own Indeed and LinkedIn posts and use outbound recruiting as a supplementary channel rather than a replacement. If your posts are producing qualified acquisitions candidates, keep running them. If the seat has been open for three months, the problem isn’t your post.
The bottom line
If your acquisitions seat has been empty for more than a month, stop refreshing the job post and start sourcing outbound this week — pull a list of roofing, restoration and solar reps in your market, and have someone who can sell make the first call.