← The Investor Fuel Blog

Buying a Self-Storage Facility: Deal Flow, LTV, Occupancy

November 17, 2026 · commercial real estate · ohio real estate · Real Estate Pros Show · self-storage acquisitions

Buying a self-storage facility is less like buying a rental and more like buying a retail business that happens to sit on dirt. Jon Farling owns 20 facilities across Ohio, all within 90 minutes of each other, and the daily work is marketing, rent raises, delinquency management and auctions — not collecting checks.

This guide covers what an investor coming from single-family, flips or multifamily actually needs to know: how Farling sources deals from a finite list of Ohio owners, the 60% LTV ceiling he underwrites to, why portfolio occupancy sits near 81% today versus nearly 100% in 2021, how automated lockouts and 50-60 monthly auctions work, and why he won’t build ground-up right now.

Key takeaways

  • Underwrite to 80-85% occupancy as normal, not the 95-100% facilities were running in 2021-2022 — Farling’s 20-site Ohio portfolio is around 81% today, and Ohio occupancy drops every winter before recovering in spring.
  • The deal universe is small enough to work by hand: roughly 2,000 facilities in Ohio, and after removing Public Storage, U-Haul and similar, a list of 500-700 owners one assistant can touch by letter, text and phone two to four times a year.
  • Cap cash-out refinances at 60% LTV and run a cash-flow test before pulling money out. Paying retail can still work if seller financing makes the terms hit your metrics.
  • Delinquent tenants are locked out at the gate automatically around 10 days past due via facility management software, with a pay link by text and email that restores access the moment the invoice clears.
  • Ground-up construction is the wrong move in most markets right now — storage and small-bay flex are both being overbuilt, ad rates are dropping, and lease-up means cutting prices for a long time just to get back to zero.
Real Estate Pros Show

From the Real Estate Pros Show


This article draws on an interview with Jon Farling on the Real Estate Pros Show, hosted by Dylan Silver.

Self-Storage Is a Business First, Real Estate Second

Farling started with four single-family rentals in 2014 and was bored with them by 2018. His words: there were months where he hoped for a maintenance call because the only activity was driving to the post office to pick up checks.

Storage is the opposite problem. Even one small facility gives you something to do every day — running marketing, reviewing rents, hunting revenue, trimming expenses. Leases are month-to-month, which means you can raise rents monthly rather than annually. That single structural difference is why storage behaves like retail: pricing is a live lever, not a lease-renewal event.

The consequence is that the skill that gets rewarded is operations, not acquisition. Farling has watched both types cycle through storage groups for years.

The people that are operators are the ones making deals work and staying in it. The people that are just deal junkies are not making things work and just go deal to deal.

Do not assume your current asset class transfers. Farling is blunt that storage is not multifamily with a different roof — people who own a lot in another class often think they can jump straight in, and the ins and outs of how a facility actually runs are what catch them. The useful preparation is not more transactions; it is having already built systems that let you work on a business rather than in it. Farling did his own flooring and painting on rental number one, then deliberately stepped further back on each of the next three. That habit, not the four doors, is what carried over.

Where the Deals Come From: Sniper Outreach in a Finite Market

Storage deal flow is a list problem, not a volume problem. Ohio has roughly 2,000 facilities. Strip out Public Storage, U-Haul and the other national operators and Farling is left with a workable universe of about 500 to 700 owners.

That list is small enough that one assistant runs the entire outreach program. Letters, texts and phone calls go out at least a couple of times a year, often three or four. There is no acquisitions team and no predictive dialer. Farling describes it as hunting with a sniper rather than a shotgun — the entire point is that owners recognize the name when they finally decide to sell.

The payoff shows up sideways. The facility he closed most recently came through a broker, and he paid more than he would have going direct. The seller picked him anyway because she already knew who he was from the outreach. He never found out what other offers were on the table; name recognition made his the one she wanted to work with.

Geography is the other constraint worth copying. Every site is in Ohio and he can reach any of them within an hour and a half, though some he has not visited in over a year. The proximity is not about showing up — it is that a single state means one set of lien laws, one labor market, one set of vendor relationships and one management structure. Expanding across state lines multiplies operational complexity faster than it multiplies deal flow, which is the wrong trade when operations are what determine whether the deal works.

The people that are operators are the ones making deals work and staying in it. The people that are just deal junkies are not making things work and just go deal to deal.

— Jon Farling, 20-facility self-storage owner, Ohio

Underwriting: Cash Flow, 60% LTV, and When Retail Price Still Works

Farling buys for cash flow and holds. Appreciation is welcome but it is not the thesis. His read on syndicators is that most are living off fees and the home-run exit — double or triple the value, then sell. He does not syndicate and does not want to.

Because he uses his own capital, every acquisition leaves him cash poor, then he restacks cash for a few months and buys again. Cash-out refinances fund part of the growth, governed by two hard rules:

  • 60% LTV or lower on any refinance, no exceptions, especially at current rates.
  • Cash flow has to keep growing after the new debt service. If pulling money out flattens cash flow, he does not pull it.

Those two tests exist specifically to stop him from forcing deals when he wants to buy and the capital is not there.

Price discipline is more flexible than you would expect. On the deal he closed three weeks before this conversation, he paid retail at best and arguably above it — but got seller financing, and the terms made the metrics work. Most of his other purchases were bought at or near retail too, including listed deals, and gained significant value within a year simply from installing his systems. That is the forced appreciation in storage: operations, not renovation.

One recent purchase does not cash flow on day one, a break from how he has always bought. He says it keeps him up at night. Worth noting from a 20-facility operator: he is willing to do it once, with eyes open, against a portfolio that can absorb it. It is not a model to start with. His earliest five facilities roughly tripled in value through COVID, which is the cushion that makes a tighter deal survivable now.

 The Investor Fuel Mastermind

Get this in the room, not just in an article

Investor Fuel is a mastermind of active real estate investors and service providers who solve problems like this one together every month. Membership is by application.

Learn About Investor Fuel

Occupancy Reality: 81% Today vs. 100% in 2021

Across Farling’s 20 sites, occupancy is about 81% today. In 2021 and 2022, most of his facilities were close to 100% full no matter what he did — there was a stretch where a third-party call center was not even answering the phones and the facilities stayed essentially full.

Anyone underwriting off 2021 comps is underwriting off an anomaly. Farling’s view of normal now is 80-85%. Some of his 81% reflects newer acquisitions this year that came in with lower occupancy, but the direction of travel is clear.

The demand driver is movement. Storage needs either a strong market where people are moving and buying houses, or a painful one where people are moving and storing. Right now nobody is moving, so neither engine is firing. That is the single variable to watch before you buy.

Ohio demand is also seasonal in a way that affects when you measure. Occupancy drops heading into the colder months, picks up around the first of the year, then climbs through spring and peaks in summer before cycling again. A trailing-twelve average tells you more than a current-month snapshot, and a December rent roll will flatter or punish you depending on which side of the cycle you are reading.

One underrated stabilizer in smaller markets: long-term tenants who are not going anywhere. Farling has units with rusted locks and cobwebs where the tenant has not visited in years but keeps paying. He also rents to contractors, tree-trimming businesses and outdoor parking for boats, RVs and moving trucks — one site is entirely outdoor parking.

Delinquency, Lockouts and the Monthly Auction Routine

Delinquency management in storage is now largely automated, and that is the biggest operational change of the last decade. At roughly 10 days past due, the tenant is locked out at the gate automatically — the facility management software talks directly to the gate, and no one on the team touches it.

The tenant gets a link by text and email, pays the past-due invoice, and gate access is restored the moment it clears. No phone call, no staff time. Ten years ago this was a person driving out to put an overlock on the door.

Auctions run on a monthly cadence. Across the portfolio, Farling averages roughly 50 to 60 auctions a month. Plenty of those never reach the block because the tenant catches up first. All auctions are now run online with video of the unit uploaded to an auction site, replacing the in-person auctions he ran early on.

The mistake worth learning from his: in year one or two, a tenant paid online about an hour before an in-person auction, it was not caught, and the unit sold anyway. He sent the tenant a check to make it right. The fix is a hard cutoff written into the lease — pay after this time and the auction proceeds regardless.

On legal exposure, use an attorney up front to set up the lease, then follow your state’s lien law. Ohio publishes its storage lien procedure and Farling follows it; after the lease is right, he does not need counsel for routine auctions. He also notes the practical reality that softens disputes: what is in most units is trash. Storage Wars is not the business. Best case you find some tools.

Buy vs. Build — and the Debt Reset Coming for Everyone

Farling does not do ground-up and calls building right now, at current occupancy levels, close to crazy. Two of his markets have developers who keep throwing up buildings with no read on demand, working off the memory of being full in 2021.

Small-bay flex and contractor garages are running the same play and getting saturated. He sees the ads on social media a few miles from his sites, and the rates keep dropping. The math on a new build in an oversupplied submarket: you may fill up, but only by cutting price, and it takes long enough that you are just working back to zero.

The narrow case where building does make sense: an undersaturated market, competitors running full, high street rates, and cash on hand rather than short-term construction debt.

On product classes, storage breaks into three. Class A is climate controlled, heated and air conditioned, often the multi-story buildings you see from the highway. Class B is a nice one-story drive-up with roll-up doors, fencing and asphalt or concrete. Class C is drive-up on gravel.

Class A is not direct competition for drive-up, and it can help you. A climate-controlled building went up about 200 yards from two of Farling’s facilities in a town where he has five locations. Their rates are higher, so he can follow them up while staying underneath — the new building raised his pricing ceiling and made his product look like value.

The bigger opportunity is debt. Three- and five-year balloons signed in 2019-2021 are coming due, banks are extending to buy time, and Farling does not see rates falling enough to save those deals. His own loans sit around 3% with a refinance roughly five years out. Operators with stable cash flow will be the buyers when others cannot refinance.

Frequently asked questions

Do you need prior real estate experience before buying your first self-storage facility?

No, but you will take more bumps and bruises without it. Farling credits his four single-family rentals with teaching him to build systems and step out of the day-to-day work — he did the flooring, painting and property management himself on the first one, then handed off more on each of the next three. That habit transferred to storage far more than the transaction count did.

If you are starting cold, invest heavily in operational education before you close. Farling learned the operations side through Storage Rebellion, a storage-specific investor community, and still participates in it.

What occupancy rate is normal for self-storage right now?

Roughly 80-85% is normal today. Farling’s 20-site Ohio portfolio is around 81%, partly because he bought several lower-occupancy facilities this year. In 2021 and 2022, 95-100% was realistic across his sites — at one point the facilities were essentially full even though a third-party call center was not answering inbound calls.

Underwrite to the 80-85% band, not the COVID-era numbers, and account for seasonality if you are in a cold-weather market. Ohio occupancy falls into winter and climbs through spring and summer.

How do self-storage auctions work when a tenant stops paying?

The tenant is locked out at the gate automatically around 10 days past due through facility management software that controls the gate, and a pay link sent by text and email restores access immediately once the past-due invoice clears. If the account is never cured, the unit goes to auction under state lien law.

Farling averages 50 to 60 auctions a month across his portfolio, though many are paid off before the block. All of them run online now, with a video of the unit posted to an auction site. Set the lease up with an attorney, then follow your state’s published lien procedure.

Is it a good time to build self-storage from the ground up?

In most markets, no. Farling says building right now would be absolutely crazy given where occupancy sits, and he sees developers in two of his markets putting up buildings with no read on actual demand. Small-bay flex and contractor garages are hitting the same oversupply, with advertised rates visibly dropping.

The exception is narrow: an undersaturated market where existing facilities are full and street rates are high, funded with cash on hand rather than short-term construction debt. Otherwise you fill up slowly at cut prices and spend years getting back to breakeven.

Does climate-controlled storage compete with drive-up facilities nearby?

Less than most buyers expect, and it can work in your favor. Climate-controlled Class A and drive-up Class B or C are different products at different price points — renters pay more for climate control, while drive-up is simpler.

Farling had a climate-controlled building go up about 200 yards from two of his facilities. Because its rates are higher, he can raise his own pricing while staying below the new building and still look like the value option.

The bottom line

Before you underwrite a single facility, build the owner list for your state and start touching it — the acquisition edge in storage comes from being the name a seller already recognizes, and it is a small enough universe that one assistant can cover it.

 The Investor Fuel Mastermind

Ready to scale with people who are already there?

Investor Fuel members close deals in every market in the country. Apply to see whether the room is a fit for where your business is headed.

Learn About Investor Fuel

The Investor Fuel Mastermind

Doing deals every month? Do them with people who do more.

Quarterly in-person masterminds, monthly boards and a community of serious real estate operators. Membership is by application.

Learn About Investor Fuel